The musical opened on Broadway at Lincoln Center's Vivian Beaumont Theater on December 10, 1992 and closed on January 10, 1993 after 36 performances and 45 previews. The cast included Evan Pappas, Tim Curry, Tom Mardirosian, Katie Finneran, Andrea Martin, Josh Mostel, and Lainie Kazan, who reprised the role of Benjy's mother she had played in the film. The show was directed by Ron Lagomarsino and choreographed by Thommie Walsh, with scenic design by Thomas Lynch, costume design by Patricia Zipprodt, and lighting design by Jules Fisher, with associate lighting designerPeggy Eisenhauer. The creative team constantly reworked the troubled production during previews. My Favorite Year received mixed-to-negative reviews. The New York Times's Frank Rich called the musical "a missed opportunity, a bustling but too frequently flat musical that suffers from another vogue of the 1950s, an identity crisis," and disapproved of the melodramatic turn taken in the show's second act, while Time magazine wrote that is a "barren Broadway musical." An original cast recording was released on the RCA Victor label. In March 2007, The Chicago Sun-Times revealed that Flaherty and Ahrens were "reworking the show with an eye on a new Broadway production." Flaherty said that, "In hindsight, I think our decision to paint the musical in somewhat darker colors was a mistake." Among the revisions made to the show are two new songs, which were incorporated into a March 2007 repertory production of the show at the Bailiwick Repertory Theatre, Chicago. Musicals Tonight! in New York City presented a staged concert in April 2003. The York Theatre Company Musicals in Mufti in New York City presented a staged concert in December 2014. Lynn Ahrens reminisced about the first time Andrea Martin sang "Professional Showbizness Comedy" -- "It Bombed". However, "By the time we got done with our rewrites...she stopped the show."
In the 1950s Benjy Stone, is a sketch writer for a live television variety show starring King Kaiser . Signed for a guest appearance is Alan Swann, a one-time movie idol whose career was disrupted by his addiction to alcohol and loose women. Benjy writes a sketch for Swann about a Musketeer and a princess being captured. The task of keeping him sober and celibate until airtime falls to Benjy, who soon finds himself involved in a sequence of shenanigans unlike any he ever experienced before. Various characters, including Benjy's pushy mother Belle Steinberg Carroca and Alan Swann's estranged daughter Tess, complicate Benjy's task. The other writers, Sy, Alice and Herb, add to the chaos.
Differences from the original film
In the film, there is a subplot surrounding King Kaiser angering Karl Rojeck, a corrupt union boss with a comedy sketch depicting Rojek as a stereotypical gangster. Neither the character of Rojeck nor the sketch that angered him, is included in the plot of the musical.
In the film's epilogue, Benjy relates that Swann agreed to visit his daughter Tess, in person; in the musical, Tess invites Swann to an award ceremony and they meet there. They also reunite in the final song.
In the film, Swann revealed he'd been keeping tabs on his daughter for sometime, without ever meeting her face to face. In the musical, Swann revealed he hadn't seen Tess in three years.
The Musketeer sketch is very minor to the plotline in the film; in the musical, it is central to the plotline, being that it is the sketch Benjy wrote for Swann. Four of the show's songs are dedicated to it.
