In June 2005, Tovey signed with his hometown team, the Perth Wildcats. However, his season was cut short after injuring his knee against West Sydney on 10 December 2005. In 22 games for the Wildcats in 2005–06, he averaged 4.5 points and 1.9 rebounds per game. In March 2006, he parted ways with the Wildcats.
In September 2006, Tovey competed with the Sutherland Sharks at the ABA National Finals, where he earned All-Star Five honours. Later that month, Tovey debuted for the Sydney Kings. In 32 games for the Kings in 2006–07, he averaged 5.0 points and 2.2 rebounds per game. After another stint with the Sutherland Sharks in 2007, Tovey helped the Kings win the minor premiership and reach the NBL Grand Final series in 2007–08. In his second season with the Kings, he averaged 6.0 points, 2.8 rebounds and 1.1 assists in 37 games. After returning to Perth in 2008 for a stint with the Kalamunda Eastern Suns, Tovey joined the Townsville Crocodiles for the 2008–09 NBL season. In 2009, Tovey played for the Townsville Heat in the Queensland Basketball League and competed with the Australian University National Team in Serbia at the World University Summer Games. Tovey then returned to the Crocodiles for the 2009–10 season.
Second stint with the Wildcats (2010–2013)
Following the conclusion of the 2009–10 season, Tovey walked out on the Crocodiles to become an accountant, moving to Perth to begin a career with KPMG which he believed would not allow him to continue his sporting career. Considered one of the league's best defenders, Tovey believed his future career had to take precedence over his present day sporting ambitions. However, in May 2010, Tovey reversed his decision to retire and signed with the Perth Wildcats. In August 2010, Tovey helped the Willetton Tigers win their first SBL Championship with a 107–96 win over the Lakeside Lightning in the grand final. He was named MVP after finishing with 31 points, nine rebounds and seven assists. Tovey's first season back with the Wildcats saw him hold down jobs as both an NBL basketballer and accountant at the same time. Despite this, he averaged career-best numbers in 2010–11 with 8.1 points, 5.0 rebounds and 2.6 assists per game. He subsequently re-joined the Willetton Tigers for the 2011 season, but he missed their finals run. Over the following two seasons, Tovey helped the Wildcats reach back-to-back NBL Grand Finals, both resulting in losses to the New Zealand Breakers. On 28 March 2013, Tovey announced his decision to retire at the conclusion of the 2012–13 season.
Personal
Tovey is the son of David and Julie Tovey, and has two sisters, Stephanie and Hannah.