Undeterred by his earlier struggles, Ormsby moved to Genoa, Utah Territory in 1857 as an agent for the Pioneer Stage Line. Ormsby and other supporters of the stage line favored western Utah Territory as the focal point of their overland stage route. Ormsby presided over a meeting in Genoa which selected Judge James Crane to go to Washington, D.C. in an effort to create a new territory, which they thought should be named "Sierra Nevada". Abraham Curry also shared the vision of a new territory and foresaw that Carson City in Eagle Valley would become the new territory's capital. Curry left a large tract of land in the center of the valley open for the possibility of a capitol building. Major Ormsby moved to Carson City and bought land to the southwest of Curry's proposed capitol site, where he constructed a hotel called the Ormsby House. His group did not succeed in 1859 in getting the federal government to designate a new territory. But, the discovery of the Comstock lode near Virginia City brought them new hope. Ormsby opened his hotel in 1860, in the wake of the Comstock Lode, as more settlers and prospectors rushed to the area. He also bought McMacklin's store and was appointed as a judge in a murder trial, indicating his stature in the town.
In 1860 Ormsby and his wife arranged for companions for their daughter Lizzie. He had become familiar with Tru-ki-zo or Truckee, a Paiute elder. Truckee brought his 13-year-old granddaughter, Sarah and her younger sister Elma Winnemucca to live at the Ormsby household. Sarah already knew some English and Spanish, and Elma some English. Sarah was learning to read and write English, and the three girls learned from one another. That year, two proprietors of Williams Station, an overland stage stop near present-day Silver Springs, kidnapped two Paiute girls and abused them. An angered group of Paiute warriors rode to Williams Station to rescue the girls, killing five white settlers and burning the station in the process. Word of the attack reached other miners and settlers, who wanted to retaliate. more than 100 vigilantes from Carson City, Virginia City, Genoa and Silver City assembled and chose Major Ormsby as their leader. Ormsby led this poorly trained and poorly armed force north from Williams Station along the Truckee River toward Pyramid Lake. The Piaute chief Numaga ambushed Ormsby on May 12, 1860 and defeated the vigilantes, killing 76 men and wounding another 29 at what came to be known as the first Battle of Pyramid Lake. Among the dead was Major Ormsby. He and other dead were first buried at the site. Ormsby's family later arranged transfer of his body and reinterment in Carson City's Pioneer Cemetery. In a third action, his remains were exhumed and his family arranged for his removal when they left the state. In June, Colonel John C. Hays defeated the Paiute with a second and better organized force.
Legacy
Ormsby County was named in his honor, and Storey County was named for Edward Farris Storey, another fatality of the Pyramid Lake War.
