Strategic Choice began his second season in the Group 3 John Porter Stakes at Newbury in April in which he started at odds of 12/1 in a ten-runner field which also included Broadway Flyer, River North, Linney Head, Right Win and Shambo. After tracking the leaders in the early stages he overtook Broadway Flyer inside the final furlong and won by a neck with a gap of three lengths back to Shambo in third. In June he was sent to Italy and finished third behind the German champion Lando in the Gran Premio di Milano and then returned to England in July to contest Britain's most prestigious weight-for-age race the King George VI and Queen Elizabeth Stakes at Ascot Racecourse. He started a 25/1 outsider but exceeded expectations as he finished a close third behind Lammtarra and Pentire, with Winged Love, Carnegie and Environment Friend finishing behind. After a six-week break Strategic Choice returned in the Grosser Preis von Baden and finished unplaced behind Germany. On 16 September the colt was sent to the Curragh Racecourse for the Irish St Leger over fourteen furlongs and started the 6/1 third favourite behind Vintage Crop and Moonax. The best fancied of the other four runners were Oscar Schindler, who went on to win the race in 1996 and 1997 and the Michael Stoute-trained Zilzal Zamaan. Strategic Choice was restrained by Quinn in the early stages and turned into the straight in fourth place behind Zilzal Zamaan, Vintage Crop and Moonax before making "smooth headway" to contest the lead in the last quarter mile. He took the lead inside the furlong and fought off a sustained challenge from Moonax to win by a head. On his only subsequent start as a four-year-old the horse was sent to Paris for the Prix de l'Arc de Triomphe at Longchamp Racecourse in October but after racing prominently in the early stages he faded in the straight and finished unplaced behind Lammtarra.
1996: five-year-old season
On his first appearance of 1996 Strategic Choice finished second to Classic Cliche in the Yorkshire Cup and was then sent to Italy for a second run in the Gran Premio di Milano. On this occasion he started favourite, went to the front before half way and won from his fellow British challengers Luso and King's Theatre. Another run in Ascot's King George followed, but he was unable to reproduce his 1995 performance and finished last of the eight runners behind Pentire. In the Grand Prix de Deauville over 2500 metres in August he started the 7/1 fourth choice in the betting behind Tarator, Water Poet and High Baroque. He took the lead after 1400 metres and despite running wide on the final turm he kept on well in the straight to win by a neck and a short head from Tarator and Percutant. In October Strategic Choice returned to Milan for the Gran Premio del Jockey Club and finished third of the eight runners behind Shantou. On his final run of the year he was sent to Japan and started a 39/1 outsider for the Japan Cup at Tokyo Racecourse on 24 November. He produced one of his best performances as he dead-heated with Helissio for third behind Singspiel and Fabulous La Fouine: the horses who finished behind him included Awad, Pentire, Dance Partner and Bubble Gum Fellow.
1997: six-year-old season
In the first half of 1997, Strategic Choice finished fifth to Helissio in the Prix Ganay and fourth behind Shantou in the Gran Premio de Milano. He ran in the King George at Ascot for a third time in July and finished sixth of the eight runners behind Swain. After finishing fourth in the Geoffrey Freer Stakes he was sent to Turkey to contest the Bosphorus Trophy over 2400 metres at Veliefendi Race Course on 14 September. He faced seven local runners including Bold Pilot as well as Aristid from Germany and Shavat from Russia. He took the lead 400 metres from the finish and won "very easily" by three lengths from Aristid and Bold Pilot despite being eased down by Quinn in the closing stages. On his final run of the season Strategic Choice was sent to Canada for the Canadian International Stakes at Woodbine Racetrack on 19 October in which he finished fourth to Chief Bearheart.
1998-2000: later career
Strategic Choice remained in training for three more seasons but never won again. In 1998 he finished second in the Yorkshire Cup, third in the Grand Prix de Deauville and fourth in the Geoffrey Freer Stakes from five runs in Europe before ending the year with an unplaced effort in the Hong Kong Vase at Sha Tin Racecourse in December. His eight-year-old campaign was restricted to two races at Newmarket: he finished fourth in the Fred Archer Stakes in June and sixth in a minor event in the following month. He was back on the track but made no impact in two starts as he finished unplaced in handicap races at Haydock Park and Newmarket in July.
Stud record
At the end of his racing career Strategic Choice was retired to stud. He was used primarily as a sire of National Hunt horses and was based at the Bracklynn Stud in Ireland. The best of his offspring included Bog Warrior and Grey Gold.
Pedigree
Strategic Choice was inbred 3 × 3 to Tom Rolfe, meaning that this stallion appears twice in the third generation of his pedigree.