The original town proprietor records of Bridgewater show the following record dated December 28, 1661: It is probable that construction began on the house the following Spring of 1662, although the same proprietor records indicate the house was not finished until 1664, after a young student of Divinity, Mr. James Keith, agreed to be the town's minister following his ordination.
Owners
Rev. James Keith
James Keith was born in Scotland in approximately 1642 or 1643. He was educated briefly at Marischal College in Aberdeen, Scotland. He is said to have immigrated to Boston, MA in late 1661 or early 1662. He was made a freeman of Plymouth Colony at Plymouth, MA on June 8, 1664. Rev. James Keith left the house to his 7 living children in his will dated July 13, 1718 to be sold "at time convenient" and divided among them. They sold the house on March 18, 1723 to William Fobes Ephraim Fobes, Sr. for the sum of 250£. The sale was made with the condition that James Keith's widow, Mary Macy Keith, be allowed to stay in the home until she either remarried or died.
Deacon Edward Fobes
On September 8, 1734, William Fobes sold his share of the house to his brother and co-owner, Deacon Ephraim Fobes, Sr. for the sum of 300£, making Ephraim the sole owner of the property. Five years later, on September 26, 1739, Ephraim sold the homestead to his son, Ephraim Fobes, Jr., who held the deed for almost 58 years, selling to Amasa Howard on March 14, 1792.
Amasa Howard
Amasa Howard only held the property for about five years before he died. He left it to his children in his will dated June 28, 1797. His two-year-old son, Adonis Howard, inherited the property between River Street and the Town River. His daughters, Arabella and Katherine Howard, both minors, received the property on the north side of River Street along with the house. These were the youngest owners in the home's history. Eventually, after a series of transactions within the family, Arabella Howard, now married to Benjamin Eaton, became the sole owner of the Keith House. She died in 1833 without a will, and the county Probate Court awarded the house to her son, Benjamin Eaton, Jr. He kept the house for less than a year before selling it to Thomas Pratt on October 9, 1834.
The Pratt Family
Thomas Pratt owned the house after purchasing it from Benjamin Eaton, Jr., and by either deed or will, the house was passed to his children, Mary and George Pratt. Mary sold her interest in the property to her brother, George, in a deed dated October 10, 1881. In 1906, George died, and the property went to his second wife, Eliza Juliet Pratt. She lived in the house until her death, and left the house to her husband's grandson, Robert H. Redman in her will dated March 6, 1930. Robert Redman retained the house until September 12, 1952, when he sold it to Howard and Jessie Anderson.
Howard and Jessie Anderson
The Andersons owned the house for nine years. They gifted it to the Old Bridgewater Historical Society on November 29, 1961.
The Old Bridgewater Historical Society
OBHS is the present owner of this historic home. They renovated of the property in the 1960s to return the home to its circa 1720 shape and layout. They currently run it as a colonial home museum.
