It is New Year's Eve and Jay wants to celebrate it with his family by taking them to a hotel in Palm Springs. Jay visited the hotel in the past and speaks highly of it. Unfortunately, the hotel being much older, is not as it was. Claire wants to have sex with Phil and learns of a nearby hot spring from the bell boy. Mitch wants to feel young again, so he and Cam also want to ditch dinner. Jay takes Gloria to sleep, but when he returns, everyone else has gone. Jay ends ups playing poker with the owner of the hotel and her friends, which include Billy Dee Williams. Phil and Claire arrive at the hot spring, but the demented bellboy forgot to say that nudists come their to celebrate the New Year as well. Now they are stuck with a bunch of naked people in a small hot spring with their clothes buried under a pile of clothes. After Mitch and Cameron escape from the dinner, they attempt to go to a bar to relive their youth. But the bar is full of young people in sleeveless clothes, while they are in formal wear. They try another place, which although is not shown, can be presumed to be a strip club. Finally, on their third try, they end up in a gay bar made up of men twice their age. Meanwhile, Alex and Haley are left back home babysitting the younger kids, Luke, Manny and Lily. Luke invites two girls over, one for him and one for Manny. Luke takes her up to his room, making it awkward for Haley and Alex, while Manny's date is a sullen, depressed weirdo, who shuns his gracious hosting. Meanwhile, Lily is completely left unattended to and at one point rang the doorbell, claiming to have seen a coyote.
Reception
Ratings
In its original American broadcast, "New Year's Eve" was watched by 12.04 million; up 1.1 from the previous episode.
Reviews
"New Year's Eve" received generally positive reviews. Ryan McGee of The A.V. Club gave a B+ grade saying that the episode was not one of the funniest but it was one of the most heartfelt. ""New Year’s Eve", which gives tonight's Modern Family episode its title, promises both the chance for a fresh start as well as a potentially stark reminder that life only moves forward in time. "New Year’s Eve" wasn't the funniest episode this season by a long stretch, but it was one of its most heartfelt. Sometimes, that's more than enough." Leigh Raines of TV Fanatic rated "Diamond in the Rough" with a 4.5/5."I think most people would agree that "New Year's Eve" is perhaps the most overrated and disappointing holiday there is. And in a hotel that looked like it hadn't changed the sheets since the mid-70s, Jay's family was bound to be let down." Dalene Rovenstine of Paste Magazine rated the episode with 8.3/10. Michael Adams from 411mania gave the episode 7/10 saying that it was not too memorable. "Although it's 10 days late, the Modern Family New Year's Eve, showed NYE from every point of view, romantic, unexpected, spontaneous, quiet/alone, and I thought each story was nicely done, but the episode as a whole was just alright. It was funny at times, as the show always is, but it wasn't too memorable."
