Multi-master replication
Multi-master replication is a method of database replication which allows data to be stored by a group of computers, and updated by any member of the group. All members are responsive to client data queries. The multi-master replication system is responsible for propagating the data modifications made by each member to the rest of the group, and resolving any conflicts that might arise between concurrent changes made by different members.
Multi-master replication can be contrasted with master-slave replication, in which a single member of the group is designated as the "master" for a given piece of data and is the only node allowed to modify that data item. Other members wishing to modify the data item must first contact the master node. Allowing only a single master makes it easier to achieve consistency among the members of the group, but is less flexible than multi-master replication.
Multi-master replication can also be contrasted with failover clustering where passive slave servers are replicating the master data in order to prepare for takeover in the event that the master stops functioning. The master is the only server active for client interaction.
The primary purposes of multi-master replication are increased availability and faster server response time.
Advantages
- Accessibility: If one master fails, other masters continue to update the database.
- Distributed Access: Masters can be located in several physical sites, i.e. distributed across the network.
Disadvantages
- Consistency: Most multi-master replication systems are only loosely consistent, i.e. lazy and asynchronous, violating ACID properties.
- Performance: Eager replication systems are complex and increase communication latency.
- Integrity: Issues such as conflict resolution can become intractable as the number of nodes involved rises and latency increases.
Implementations
Directory services
Many directory servers are based on LDAP and implement multi-master replication.Active Directory
One of the more prevalent multi-master replication implementations in directory servers is Microsoft's Active Directory. Within Active Directory, objects that are updated on one Domain Controller are then replicated to other domain controllers through multi-master replication. It is not required for all domain controllers to replicate with each other as this would cause excessive network traffic in large Active Directory deployments. Instead, domain controllers have a complex update pattern that ensures that all servers are updated in a timely fashion without excessive replication traffic. Some Active Directory needs are however better served by Flexible single master operation.CA Directory
supports multi-master replication.OpenDS/OpenDJ
implemented multi-master since version 1.0.The OpenDS/OpenDJ multi-master replication is asynchronous, it uses a log with a publish-subscribe mechanism that allows scaling to a large number of nodes. OpenDS/OpenDJ replication does conflict resolution at the entry and attribute level. OpenDS/OpenDJ replication can be used over a Wide Area Network.
OpenLDAP
The widely used open source LDAP server implements multi-master replication since its version 2.4 .Database Management Systems
Apache CouchDB
uses a simple, HTTP-based multi-master replication system built from its use of an append only data-store and use of Multiversion Concurrency Control.Each document contains a revision ID, so every record stores the evolutionary timeline of all previous revision IDs leading up to itself—which provides the foundation of CouchDB's MVCC system. Additionally, it keeps a by-sequence index for the entire database. "The replication process only copies the last revision of a document, so all previous revisions that were only on the source database are not copied to the destination database."
The CouchDB replicator acts as a simple HTTP client acting on both a source and target database. It compares current sequence IDs for the database, calculates revision differences, and makes the necessary changes to the target based on what it found in the history of the source database. Bi-directional replication is the result of merely doing another replication with the source and target values swapped.
ArangoDB
is a native multi-model database system using multi-master replication. Clusters in ArangoDB use the CP master/master model with no single point of failure. When cluster encounters a network partition, ArangoDB prefers to maintain its internal consistency over availability. Clients experience the same view of the database regardless of which node they connect to. And, the cluster continues to serve requests even when one machine fails.Cloudant
, a distributed database system, uses largely the same HTTP API as Apache CouchDB, and exposes the same ability to replicate using Multiversion Concurrency Control. Cloudant databases can replicate between each other, but internally, nodes within Cloudant clusters use multi-master replication to stay in sync with each other and provide high availability to API consumers.eXtremeDB Cluster
eXtremeDB Cluster is the clustering sub-system for McObject's eXtremeDB embedded database product family. It maintains database consistency across multiple hardware nodes by replicating transactions in a synchronous manner. An important characteristic of eXtremeDB Cluster is transaction replication, in contrast to log file-based, SQL statement-based, or other replication schemes that may or may not guarantee the success or failure of entire transactions. Accordingly, eXtremeDB Cluster is an ACID compliant system ; a query executed on any cluster node will return the same result as if executed on any other cluster node.Oracle
implement multi-master replication using one of two methods. multi-master replication commits data changes to a deferred transaction queue which is periodically processed on all databases in the cluster. Synchronous multi-master replication uses Oracle's two phase commit functionality to ensure that all databases with the cluster have a consistent dataset.Microsoft SQL
provides multi-master replication through peer-to-peer replication. It provides a scale-out and high-availability solution by maintaining copies of data across multiple nodes. Built on the foundation of transactional replication, peer-to-peer replication propagates transactionally consistent changes in near real-time.MySQL / MariaDB
At a basic level, it is possible to achieve a multi-master replication scheme beginning since MySQL version 3.23 with circular replication.Departing from that, MariaDB and MySQL ship with some replication support, each of them with different nuances.
In terms of direct support we have:
MariaDB: natively supports multi-master replication since version 10.0, but conflict resolution is not supported, so each master must contain different databases. On MySQL this is named multi-source available since version .
MySQL: MySQL Group Replication, a plugin for virtual synchronous multi master with conflict handling and distributed recovery was released with .
Cluster Projects:
MySQL Cluster supports conflict detection and resolution between multiple masters since version 6.3 for true multi-master capability for the MySQL Server.
There is also an external project, Galera Cluster created by , that provides true multi-master capability, based on a fork of the InnoDB storage engine and custom replication plug-ins. Replication is synchronous, so no conflict is possible.
Percona XtraDB Cluster also is a combination of galera replication library and MySQL supporting multi master.
PostgreSQL
Various options for synchronous multi-master replication exist. Postgres-XL which is available under the Mozilla Public License, and which is available under the same license as PostgreSQL itself are examples. Note that the project was abandoned in 2007.The replication documentation for PostgreSQL categorises the different types of replication available. Various options exist for distributed multi-master, including , and BDR .