| Best Feature: | Mud Season; dir. Anthony Hall | - |
| John Garfield Award for Best Actor: | Noble Willingham The Corndog Man | Russ DeWees Mud Season |
| Geraldine Page Award for Best Actress: | Linda Shing Mud Season | - |
| Best Director of a Feature Film: | Richard Schenkman, Went to Coney Island on a Mission from God, Be Back By Five | - |
| Best Screenplay in a Feature: | Richard Schenkman, Went to Coney Island on a Mission from God, Be Back By Five | - |
| Maverick Award for Quality in a Low-budget film: | My Brother Jack; dir. Anthony Caldarella | - |
| Audience Award, Feature: | Do You Wanna Dance | - |
| Best Actor, Feature Film: | Noble Willingham The Corndog Man | - |
| Best Supporting Actor, Feature Film: | George Woodard Mud Season | - |
| Best Supporting Actress in a Feature Film: | Daphne Ashbrooke Dumbarton Bridge | - |
| Festival Director's Maverick Film Award: | Kirk Harris My Sweet Killer | Peter Gerety Went to Coney Island on a Mission from God, Be Back By Five |
| Jury Award for Best Short Film: | The Lonelys; dir. Henry Barrial | - |
| Best Director, Short Film: | J. Miller Tobin 4 AM Open All Night | - |
| Audience Award, Short Film: | Creampuff; dir.Jared Seide | - |
| Best Actor in a Short Film: | Matt Casada The Lonelys | - |
| Best Actress in a Short Film: | Danna Hansen Every Night and Twice on Sundays | - |
| The Method Fest Lifetime Achievement Award: | Maximillian Schell | - |
| The Method Fest Indie Supporter Award: | Karen Black | - |
| Best Feature: | Stanley's Gig | - |
| John Garfield Award for Best Actor: | Hill Harper The Visit | - |
| Geraldine Page Award for Best Actress: | Robin Dearden Last Chance | - |
| Festival Director's Breakout Filmmaking Award: | The Young Unknowns; dir. Catherine Jelski | Trash; dir. Mark Anthony Galluzzo |
| Best Director, Feature Film: | Bryan Cranston Last Chance | - |
| Best Screenplay, Feature Film: | Post-Mortem Louis Belanger | - |
| Maverick Award for Quality in a Low-budget film: | The Stonecutter; dir. Stephen Ericksen | - |
| Audience Award, Feature Film: | The Visit | - |
| Audience Award, Short Film: | Mutual Love Life | - |
| Best Supporting Actor, Feature Film: | Brent Glenen Rollercoaster | - |
| Best Supporting Actress, Feature Film: | Marla Gibbs The Visit | - |
| Best Short Film: | Boundaries; dir. Greg Durbin | - |
| Best Director, Short Film: | J. Miller Tobin 4 AM Open All Night | - |
| Best Actor in a Short Film: | Allen Garfield Men Named Milo Women Named Greta | - |
| Best Actress in a Short Film: | Tippi Hedren Mulligans! | - |
| Best Feature: | I'll Wave Back; dir. Jefferson Davis | - |
| Best Short Film | Egg; dir. Jacques Thelemaque | - |
| Best Actress: | Romy Rosemont in I'll Wave Back | - |
| Best Supporting Actor: | Matthew Faber in Hard Luck | - |
| Best Supporting Actress: | Rusty Schwimmer in I'll Wave Back | - |
| Breakout Acting Award: | D.W. Warren in Lansdown | - |
| Maverick Actor Award: | Jon Jacobs in Hard Luck | - |
| Best Director | I'll Wave Back; dir. Jefferson Davis | - |
| Best Screenplay | Finder's Fee; Jeff Probst | - |
| Maverick Film Award: | Falling Like This; dir. Dani Minnick | Hard Luck; dir. Jack Rubio |
| Festival Director's Breakout Filmmaking Award | The Restless | Falling Like This |
| Festival Director's Award for Excellence in Acting | Kirk Harris | Irina Bjorklund |
| Lifetime Achievement Award | James Earl Jones | - |
| Best Feature: | Sunday; dir. Charles McDougall |
| Best Short Film | 5 Minutes; dir. Larry Pennell |
| Best Actress in a Short: | Falsehood Anne Welles |
| Best Actress in a Feature: | Walk Backwards Laurie Baranyay |
| Best Supporting Actress: | Suspended Lin Shaye |
| Best Director | Sunday; dir. Charles McDougall |
| Best Writer/Director | Falsehood Kenneth Lui |
| Best Student Film | Falsehood ; dir. Kenneth Lui |
| Festival Director's Breakout Filmmaking Award | Killer Me Zachary Hansen |
| Audience Award | Falsehood ; dir. Kenneth Lui |
| Lifetime Achievement Award | Rod Steiger |
| Best Feature: | Chained for Life; dir. Aaron Schimberg | |
| Best Short Film: | The Critic; dir. Stella Velon | |
| Best Actress in a Feature: | Tayler Buck in Princess of the Row | |
| Best Actor in a Feature: | Ethan Hawke in Stockholm | John Rezaj in Albanian Gangster |
| Break Out Acting Award in a Feature: | Edi Gathegi in Princess of the Row | |
| Best Director Feature: | Windows on the World Michael D. Olmos | |
| Best Supporting Actor in a Feature: | Edward James Olmos in Windows on the World | |
| Best Supporting Actress in a Feature: | Allison Tolman in Speed of Life | |
| Best Screenplay Feature: | Windows on the World; Robert Mailer Anderson and Zack Anderson | |
| Best Actress in a Short: | Kirstin Anderson in S_15 | |
| Best Actor in a Short: | Stéphane Monpetit in Without Saying Goodbye | |
| Best Director Short: | Mixed Signals Tracie Laymon | |
| Audience Award Feature: | Princess of the Row; dir. Max Carlson | |
| Audience Award Short Film: | The Rat; dir. Carlen May-Mann | |
| Generations of Cinematic Excellence Award: | Edward James Olmos and Michael D. Olmos | |
| The Festival Director Award for an Outstanding Performance: | Jon Jacobs in Lost Angelas | |
| Maverick Award for Quality in Low-Budget Feature: | A Room Full of Nothing; dir. Elena Weinberg and Duncan Coe | |
| Best Ensemble Cast: | Confessional; dir. Brad Gottfred | |
| Best Foreign Feature: | Sofia; dir. Meryem Benm'Barek-Aloïsi | |
