Known for his irascible personality, especially when under the influence of alcohol, Hoover on April 1, 1879, stormed into the Fairplay House Hotel and shot and mortally wounded Thomas M. Bennett, a native of Iowa, who was waiting on customers at the counter. Hoover told Bennett that he was taking charge of the hotel because he owned the building, an untruth. When the dying Bennett was asked what could have provoked Hoover, he replied, "No, no, no, oh, my God, he did it in cold blood." Hoover declared temporary insanity based on an injury that he had received in an 1871 mining accident in the now ghost town of Oro City, near Leadville in Lake County, Colorado, where he had fallen sixty-five feet down a mineshaft. Hoover told authorities that his injury from the mining accident caused him to engage in "temporary fits of insanity." Three witnesses could attest to his accident, Hoover said, but none could travel to Fairplay at the time of the trial. With the approval of District Attorney C. W. Burris, Hoover was allowed to change his plea from "Not guilty of murder" to "Guilty of manslaughter. The Colorado Fourth Judicial District Court Judge Thomas M. Bowen gave Hoover an eight-year imprisonment. A year was reduced for his plea of manslaughter, and a second year was credited for time already served while awaiting trial.
The lynching
Hoover was scheduled to be transported to the Colorado State Penitentiary in Cañon City, when early one morning ten to twenty irate citizens, who considered the imprisonment too lenient a punishment for such a heinous crime, broke into the jail in the courthouse in Fairplay and hanged Hoover from a second floor window. Law enforcement officers claimed that they could not find out who was responsible for the crime because the men wore masks and disguised their voices. Hence the actions of the mob went unpunished. Judge Bowen and DA Burris promptly left town, apparently fearful that the mob could pursue them for having participated in meting out such a light sentence in the case. Bowen, like the murder victim Bennett, was an Iowa native. He obtained great wealth in the gold fields of Rio Grande County in southern Colorado. A Republican, Bowen later served in the Colorado House of Representatives from 1882 to 1883 and the United States Senate from 1883 to 1889.
Aftermath
Hoover, who had been a Fairplay town alderman, is interred at the Fairplay Cemetery near his infant daughter, Louisa, who died at thirteen months in 1878. In 1883, his wife, the former Euphrasia Maxey, married Chandler Potter, who took her to Honduras, where he was employed by a mining company. Ward Maxey, Hoover's brother-in-law, took over Hoover's billiard parlor and later became a sheep rancher. The courthouse building where Hoover was hanged, then only six years old, was in 2013 still in use as the location of the Fairplay library.
