Chisum was a business associate of Alexander McSween, an influential figure in the Lincoln County War. When Lew Wallace took office as the appointed Territorial Governor of New Mexico on October 1, 1878, he proclaimed an amnesty for all those involved in the bitter feud. When Billy the Kid surrendered to the authorities, he was told he would be charged with the death of Sheriff William J. Brady, violating the amnesty. Billy the Kid escaped from custody and went to see Chisum to collect a $500 debt. Chisum refused payment, claiming that he instead had given the Kid horses, supplies, and protection over the years. The Kid promised to steal $500 worth of cattle from Chisum to make up this sum. The Kid's gang also stole from other cattlemen and became a serious problem in Lincoln County. Ultimately, Chisum, Pecos Valley rancher Joseph C. Lea, and James Dolan sought somebody capable of hunting down the Kid and either arresting or killing him. In 1880, they persuaded Pat Garrett, a former buffalo hunter and cowboy, reformed part-time rustler, small rancher, and Billy the Kid’s one-time friend, to run for the office of Lincoln County sheriff. His specific task, if elected, was to apprehend Billy’s gang, consisting ofDave Rudabaugh, Billy Wilson, Tom O'Folliard, and Charlie Bowdre. In December 1880, Garrett shot O'Folliard and Bowdre dead. Billy the Kid, Rudabaugh, and Wilson were later captured or killed by Garrett.
Death and legacy
Chisum died in Eureka Springs, Arkansas, on December 23, 1884, aged 60, due to complications from surgery to remove a growth from his jaw. He was unmarried and left his estate worth $500,000 to his brothers Pitzer and James. Chisum had an extended family living with him at the South Springs ranch in Roswell, and this family, along with hired help, often numbered two dozen at the main ranch headquarters. Chisum's niece Sallie Lucy Chisum, daughter of his brother James, became a beloved figure in the area, where she lived until 1934. Sallie kept a diary or journal that has historical importance because of its references to Billy the Kid and Pat Garrett, both of whom she knew. She and John Chisum are honored by statues to their memory in Artesia and Roswell, New Mexico. In 1958, he was inducted into the Hall of Great Westerners of the National Cowboy & Western Heritage Museum.
Media and literary portrayals
Chisum's story has been portrayed on film by John Wayne in Chisum and James Coburn in Young Guns II. As a supporting character, Chisum has been portrayed in several television shows and movies, including 1953's San Antone ; the 1960 episode of Bronco titled "Death of an Outlaw" ; 1973's Pat Garrett & Billy the Kid ; and the 2011 UK film Birth of a Legend: Billy the Kid & The Lincoln County War. Michael Constantine was cast as the historical John Chisum in the 1965 episode "Paid in Full" of the syndicated television anthology seriesDeath Valley Days hosted by Ronald Reagan. Keith Andes portrayed Rob Hunter, a former Confederatecolonel who visits Kathy McLennan, the wife of a soldier who had been killed while serving under Hunter in the American Civil War. He discovers that McLennan and her neighboring ranchers have been defrauded by Chisum, who issued legally unclaimable IOUs when he purchased their stock. Hunter works to recover the money owed to the ranchers. Tyler McVey was cast as Chisum in an earlier 1956 Death Valley Days episode, "Pat Garrett's Side of It", with Alex Sharp as Garrett and Joel Collins as Billy the Kid. John Chisum's life from 1837, and his fabled relationship with a slave, are the subject of a semi-biographical 2019 novel by Russ Brown titled Miss Chisum.