Peter Vollmer, the leader of a small and struggling Nazi group, is mocked and ridiculed by the crowds he preaches to on street corners. Ernst Ganz, the elderly Jewish man that Peter has had a sympathetic, uncle-like relationship with since he was an abused and neglected kid, offers him shelter and compassion but not respect. Ernst spent nine years in Dachau and recognizes that Peter's politics stem from a childish desire for the respect of others. This pains Peter, who openly confesses that he sees Ernst as his father, since his real father physically abused him and his mother was never around. Beginning one night, Peter is periodically visited by a shadowy figure who teaches him how to enthrall a crowd. The figure teaches Peter how to speak. The figure pays Peter's rent at the hall where he holds rallies, and instructs him to arrange the death of one of his followers, Nick, thereby creating a martyr to rally everyone around. Following the figure's instructions and assistance, Peter is considerably more successful and his group's following grows. Ernst becomes fearful that Peter may actually succeed in igniting another Holocaust. He disrupts a rally, accusing Peter of being "nothing but a cheap copy" of the German Führer while Peter cowers before his surrogate father. After the failed rally, the shadowy figure rebukes Peter for his failure and says that from now on he will be ordering Peter rather than instructing him. Peter demands to know who his mysterious benefactor is. The man steps forward from the shadows to reveal himself to be Adolf Hitler. He orders Peter to kill Ernst. Peter steels himself enough to complete the task. Hitler congratulates him and asks how it felt. Peter replies that he felt immortal. Hitler responds, "Mr. Vollmer! We ARE immortal!" Afterwards, police arrive to arrest Peter for conspiracy to murder Nick. Shot while fleeing, Peter is astonished by the sight of his own blood. Hitler's shadow appears on the wall behind Peter, who gasps out, "There's something very wrong here...Don't you understand that I'm made out of steel!?"
Closing narration
Production
Rod Serling was particularly pleased with the script for "He's Alive", and was dismayed when he learned that a scene set between Hitler's revealing himself and Vollmer's returning to Hitler was cut due to length constraints. This prompted the idea of doing two versions of "He's Alive": a short version for television, and a longer version for theatrical release as a feature film. His extended script added a number of scenes and even a new protagonist, an FBI agent who investigates Vollmer's neo-Nazi movement, but with The Twilight Zones budget already stretched to the breaking point, Serling's proposal was turned down. The scene following Hitler revealing himself was filmed, but the footage has since been lost.
