Playing at hooker, Tyler played for the City club in Auckland, and with them won seven senior Auckland championships between 1900 and 1911. From there he was selected for Auckland starting in 1899, and continued to represent his province until 1911. Tyler was first selected for New Zealand for their 1903 tour of Australia. Tyler played in all eleven of the sides matches, including the game against Wellington immediately before their departure. The team won all ten of their Australian matches, including winning their first ever Test matchagainst Australia in Sydney. Tyler was one of only four players, and only two forwards, that played all ten matches. The following year Tyler played for Auckland in the first ever Ranfurly Shield matchwhich Auckland lost to Wellington. He then played for New Zealand in their first ever home Test matchagainst the British Isles. The British side were touring New Zealand and Australia, and had gone through their Australian-leg unbeaten before facing New Zealand in Wellington. The New Zealanders won 9–3 to inflict the first defeat on the British. A week later Tyler was in the Auckland team that faced the tourists. The result was an even more comprehensive victory, with Tyler and the other forwards dominating their opponents. He was selected for the historic tour to the British Isles and France in 1905. The side played five Testsagainst Scotland, Ireland, England, Wales and Francewith Tyler appearing in all of them. The only loss of the 35 match tour matches was the Welsh Test match, a narrow and controversial 3–0 loss. Tyler appeared in 23 of the tour matches, but is most notably remembered for shaking the hands with King Edward VII. Eight of the All Blacks met King Edward VII while visiting a cattle show in Islington, with the monarch shaking Tyler's hand and congratulating him on the team's success. He was selected for the All Blacks again in 1907, but declined to play because of work commitments. He continued to play rugby for Auckland until 1911, and was also involved in swimming, rowing and yachting. Tyler died at his home in Auckland on 15 April1942, and was buried at Waikaraka Cemetery.
