Abell's first-class debut came for Worcestershire against Essex at Worcester in August 1923; he had a quiet match, claiming no dismissals and scoring 1 and 6 not out. Indeed, in three further appearances that season he appeared on the scorecard only once as a fielder: when he caught Gloucestershire captain Philip Williams off the bowling of Fred Root. Abell scored 50 in the second innings of this game, the only half-century he would make for nearly two years. The 1924 season saw Abell play 12 first-class matches: seven for Oxford University and five for Worcestershire. His batting produced nothing of note but he held 12 catches and made two stumpings. The following year, however, he passed 500 runs for the only time in his career, this total including 124 for Worcestershire against Sussex. He also claimed 17 dismissals. From 1926 until 1928 he performed poorly with the bat, 50 being his highest score in 31 innings, but he continued to pick up victims behind the stumps. From 1928–29 to 1934–35 he played all his first-class cricket in India for a variety of sides, including Europeans, the Punjab Governor's XI — for whom he made 92 and 116 against Muslims in March 1929 — and even on one occasion for India itself, against Ceylon. However, the undoubted highlight of his career was the 210 he scored for Northern India against Army in the first Ranji Trophy in 1934–35, the first double century made in the competition. Northern India reached the final for the only time that season; Abell captained them against Bombay but Vajifdar's second-innings 8–40 for Bombay ensured a heavy defeat for Northern India. Abell returned to play in England during the second half of the 1935 season, and he also had a few matches in 1939. Most of these games were for Worcestershire, for whom he acted as captain three times in 1939, but he also turned out for Marylebone Cricket Club on a handful of occasions. His final first-class game of all was at Lahore, as captain of Northern India against Southern Punjab in the 1941–42 Ranji Trophy. He made one stumping, held two catches and scored 11 and 2 as Northern India ran out 74-run winners. Two of Abell's sons, John and Timothy, had very brief first-class careers. His brother-in-lawClaude Ashton had had a much more substantial career with Essex and Cambridge, while his uncle Ted Sale turned out a few times for Europeans.