Evans attended the University of Notre Dame, where he played at left halfback for the school's football team starting as a sophomore in 1940. He moved to fullback the following year, when Notre Dame went undefeated under coach Frank Leahy. Evans led the team in rushing yards and scoring in 1941. Evans was considered shy but tough. Before a game against the University of Southern California in 1941, Bill Riordan, a teammate, poured a bucket of water over Evans's head. Evans tried to retaliate but crashed into a wall and split his knee open. He concealed the injury from Leahy and played in the USC game, but needed 11 stitches afterward. After graduating in 1942, Evans was drafted by the Chicago Bears of the National Football League. His professional football career, however, was delayed by service in World War II. Evans signed up for the United StatesArmy Air Corps and flew P-51 Mustangs with the Flying Tigers, a unit that defended China against Japanese incursion during the war. While in the air corps, Evans played for the Randolph Field Ramblers, a military team at Randolph Air Force Base in San Antonio, Texas. Randolph won the national service title in 1944, when Evans was on the team.
Professional career
In 1945, Evans became the fourth player signed by the Cleveland Browns, a team under formation in the new All-America Football Conference, which was to start play in 1946. Evans was the first player to score points for the Browns in their inaugural exhibition game on August 30 against the Brooklyn Dodgers at the Akron Rubber Bowl. He scored a touchdown on a seven-yard pass from quarterbackCliff Lewis; he later intercepted a pass and returned it 83 yards for another touchdown. Later in the season, Evans twisted his knee and was sidelined for more than a month. The Browns went on to win the first AAFC championship in 1946. Before the beginning of the 1947 season, Evans was sent to the Buffalo Bills in a special draft designed to help the AAFC's weaker teams. He played for the Chicago Rockets and Chicago Bears in 1947 and 1948.
Evans came back to Cleveland after his football career and owned a dry cleaning business, with his wife Dorothy Evans, called Handee Cleaners in the city's West Park area. He transferred ownership of the business to his son Mark after he retired. Evans died in 2007. He has 5 children With Dorothy Jane Evans. Fred, Mark, Pat, Mimi, and Pam.