After serving a two-year stint in the United States Air Force, Navarro headed to Teachers College at Columbia University, where the head football coach Lou Little offered him the job of assistant offensive line coach under John F. Bateman in 1955. Little's offer ended Navarro's pursuit of teaching and put him on a path to a career in coaching. Navarro joined the Williams College coaching staff in 1957 as an assistant to head coach, Len Watters, where Navarro introduced the “Monster Defense". In 1961 and 1962, the Ephs won 12 games and 8 of those wins came by shutting out the opposition. The "Monster Defense" was designed for the linemen to tie up the blockers and allow the linebackers to make the tackles. The monster defense featured a new technique: slanting defensive linemen. The monster, or the scrape linebacker, was the one who was targeted to make tackles after the linemen tied up the offensive line. Navarro succeeded Watters as head coach in 1963 amassed a record of 28–11–1 in five season, including a 7–0–1 mark in 1967, when he was named New England CollegeCoach of the year. While Navarro was at Williams, Norman Rockwell used him as a model his painting, "The Recruit". After the 1967 season, Navarro left Williams to become the head football coach at Columbia. He led the Lions to an impressive 6–3 mark in 1971, with the three losses coming by a combined total of just eight points. 1971 was only the third winning campaigns for Columbia since 1952. Navarro was named the New York Writers Association Eastern CollegeCoach of the Year. Navarro moved on to Wabash College in Crawfordsville, Indiana in 1974. During his four years there, he led the LWabash Little Giants to a combined 26–17 record, including an 18–5 mark over his final two seasons. Wabash had not had a winning season for ten consecutive years until Navarro led them to a 7–3 record in 1976. 1977 was even better as he directed the Little Giants to a 11–2 mark and a runner-up finish in the NCAA Division III Football Championship, were they lost a 39–36 shootou to. At Princeton, Navarro's most gratifying season came in 1981 when the Tigers finished 5–4–1, including a stunning 35–31 last-second win over defending Ivy League champion, Yale, snapping Princeton's 15=game losing streak to the rival Bulldogs. For his outstanding coaching performance in that game, Navarro was named UPI Coach of the Week. By beating Yale and tying Harvard, Princeton captured its first Big Three title since 1966. The Tigers's 5–1–1 Ivy mark was their best league record since they won a share of the title in 1969.
Family
Navarro's son, Ben Navarro is a billionaire businessman, the founder and CEO of Sherman Financial Group.
