In New York City, Rachel Berry confirms that she is not pregnant, and Santana Lopez remains convinced that Brody Weston is hiding something. Unbeknownst to them, he is moonlighting as a gigolo to pay his NYADA tuition. In Lima, New Directions, noticing tension between Will Schuester and Finn Hudson , decides to assign them a week of songs covering musical feuds. Wade "Unique" Adams confronts Ryder Lynn over interfering in the relationship between Marley Rose and Jake Puckerman, and they fight after Ryder refers to Unique as a boy. Artie Abrams suggests that they express their feelings through song, and they duet on "The Bitch Is Back" and "Dress You Up", but Ryder still struggles to accept Unique as a girl. Meanwhile, Marley reconciles with Jake, but he acts hostile towards Ryder for betraying him by kissing Marley. In NYC, Santana confronts Brody at NYADA, performing "Cold Hearted" to mock him. Upon learning about this, Rachel and Kurt Hummel kick Santana out of their apartment. In Lima, Will and Finn duet on "Bye Bye Bye" and "I Want It That Way", and although Will forgives Finn, he tells Finn that their relationship can never be the same. Marley later convinces Finn that he is a natural leader and encourages him to get a teacher's degree. Santana eventually discovers Brody's secret and calls Finn, who travels to NYC and confronts Brody in a motel, threatening to tell Rachel the truth if Brody doesn't leave her alone. When Brody attempts to prevent Finn from leaving, they get into a fight, with Finn beating Brody and saying "Stay away from my future wife!" Cheerleading coach Sue Sylvester attempts to force Blaine Anderson to rejoin the Cheerios, and after he refuses, she initiates a series of attacks on his personal life. Blaine challenges Sue to a duel, and they sing "I Still Believe" and "Super Bass". Sue is elected the winner and welcomes Blaine into the Cheerios, naming him co-captain alongside Becky Jackson, unaware that this is part of Blaine and Sam Evans's plan to prevent Sue from further threatening the glee club once they graduate. Ryder begins chatting online with a girl named Katie Fitzgerald, who convinces him to make amends with his friends. Ryder calls Marley, Jake, and Unique and apologizes to them. They are joined by Kitty Wilde, who reminds them that, after the seniors graduate, they'll be taking over glee club. Ryder and Jake lead New Directions in a performance of "Closer" to celebrate their strengthened bond, and Ryder later messages Katie to thank her. However, when he asks if they can meet, he hears typing coming from the school library before Katie mysteriously goes offline.
Production
The episode was written by Glee producer Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa and directed by co-executive producer Bradley Buecker. Recurring characters in this episode include glee club members Wade "Unique" Adams, Marley Rose, Jake Puckerman, Kitty Wilde and Ryder Lynn, cheerleader Becky Jackson and NYADA junior Brody Weston. Nine songs from the episode are being released as six singles. These include three mash-ups, *NSYNC's "Bye Bye Bye" with Backstreet Boys' "I Want It That Way" performed by Morrison and Monteith, Elton John's "The Bitch Is Back" with Madonna's "Dress You Up" sung by Jenner and Newell, and Mariah Carey's "I Still Believe" with Nicki Minaj's "Super Bass" performed by Criss and Lynch, and the individual songs Tegan and Sara's "Closer" sung by Jenner and Artist, Marina and the Diamonds' "How to Be a Heartbreaker" performed by Geyer and Michele, and Paula Abdul's "Cold Hearted" performed by Rivera.
Reception
Ratings
The episode was watched by 5.37 million American viewers and received a 2.0/6 rating/share among adults 18-49. The show finished third in its timeslot against Person of Interest and Grey's Anatomy. This was a decrease from the previous episode "Girls On Film," which was watched by 6.72 million viewers and received a 2.4/7 rating/share among adults 18-49. 2.73 million viewers watched this episode via DVR, bringing the total viewership to 8.10 million and a 3.2 18-49 rating.
Critical reception
Tierney Bricker of E! Online praised Will and Finn's "boy-band off," saying "'Twas awesome!" She also complimented Finn's realized dream and confrontation with Brody. She ranked this episode as one of Thursday's "Best TV Moments." Erin Strecker of Entertainment Weekly was less thrilled about Will and Finn's musical performance, saying "The number was 100% ridiculous but honestly had 100% of the things I wanted to see once I heard the song happening. Schu on strings! Schu with JT hair! The girls being crazed fans!" Erin complimented Finn and Will's storyline, but then said "Perhaps because the plotline was so serious, the rest of the episode was completely silly," specifically talking about Blaine's subplot. Jane Lynch submitted this episode for consideration due to her nomination for the Primetime Emmy Award for Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Comedy Series at the 65th Primetime Emmy Awards.
