The region's mining work was seasonal; during the rest of the year, between April and August, miners would work in the fields to supplement wages before they returned to the mines. However, the droughts in the prairies and the overall economic situation in Canada made that impossible. That led to an increasing number of men looking for work in the mines, which let mining companies to choose their workers. Furthermore, according to the Royal Commission that investigated the strike, Saskatchewan miners made half as much as their counterparts in Alberta and in British Columbia. Most of the miners and their families lived within company housing. Annie Barylik, the sixteen-year-old daughter of a miner at Bienfait Mine,s described the conditions:
One bedroom, two beds in there, dining room, no beds in there, kitchen, one bed, and eleven in the family.... I think we need a bigger place than that. When it is raining the rain comes in the kitchen. There is only one ply of paper, cardboard paper nailed to about two-inch wood board.... It is all coming down and cracked... When the weather is frosty, when you wake up in the morning you cannot walk on the floor because it is all full of snow, right around the room.
Miners assembled in Estevan with their families to parade through the city to draw attention to their strike. The RCMP confronted them and attempted to block and break up the procession. Police violence broke out, and the RCMP opened fire on the strikers and killed three people. Many other strikers were wounded and arrested. Annie Buller, working with the Workers' Unity League, spoke in Estevan in support of the striking workers. After the riot, Buller was charged and sentenced to one year of hard labour, to be completed at the Battleford Jail, and a $500 fine.
Resolution
After a meeting with Royal Commission Counsel, members of both parties signed the following agreement:
We, the mine operators and employees in conference at the court-house Estevan, this sixth day of October, 1931, hereby agree that the mines be opened immediately and the men return to work on following conditions, viz.:
That this be considered a temporary arrangement pending the findings of the Wylie Royal Commission and the possible drafting of a working agreement between the operators and the men.
That committees of employees for each mine be a recognized organization in each mine.
That the provisions of the Mines Act be observed in relation to check-weighers.
That all water in the roadways and working face be removed by the company and that such places be kept as dry as possible.
That the terms of any schedule or agreement finally reached between the operators and the men be made retroactive to the date of re-commencement of work by them.
That there shall be no victimization or discrimination against men on account of the strike, particularly in reference to men on the payrolls as at September 7 last.
That contract men be employed on an eight-hour basis, face to face, and the company men work nine hours a day.
That because of working conditions in the various mines. the removal of slack and questions of overweight be left to negotiations between the operators and the committees of employees.
Legacy
The event is still controversial in Estevan. The three striking miners killed have the inscription "murdered by RCMP" on their headstone, and locals still alternately erase and restore those words. The Saskatchewan Federation of Labour has created a plaque to memorialize the strikers.
Popular culture
The riot was depicted in the controversial movie Prairie Giant: the Tommy Douglas Story in which Tommy Douglas is falsely portrayed to be present. Also, James Garfield Gardiner was portrayed as being premier of Saskatchewan at the time although it was really James Thomas Milton Anderson. The riot was depicted by James Keeleghan in the title track of the Small Rebellions album in 1990.
