Taylor lived in several states before spending most of his youth in Wyoming and Ohio. In his youth, he admired world and Olympic champion Cael Sanderson, who is from the nearby state of Utah.
In 2018, Taylor became the twelfth American wrestler to win the Golden Grand Prix Ivan Yarygin, a major wrestling tournament held annually in Siberia. He followed that effort up by winning continental and world titles.
Freestyle matches
! colspan="7"| Senior Freestyle Matches ! Res. ! Record ! Opponent ! Score ! Date ! Event ! Location ! style=background:white colspan=7 | Austin, Texas ! style=background:white colspan=7 | Ottawa, Canada ! style=background:white colspan=7 | Buenos Aires, Argentina ! style=background:white colspan=7 | Budapest, Hungary ! style=background:white colspan=7 | Istanbul, Turkey ! style=background:white colspan=7 | State College, Pennsylvania ! style=background:white colspan=7 | Lima, Peru ! style=background:white colspan=7 | Las Vegas, Nevada ! style=background:white colspan=7 | Iowa City, Iowa ! style=background:white colspan=7 | Krasnoyarsk, Russia ! style=background:white colspan=7 | Tehran, Iran ! style=background:white colspan=7 | Lincoln, Nebraska ! style=background:white colspan=7 | New York City, New York ! style=background:white colspan=7 | Las Vegas, Nevada ! style=background:white colspan=7 | Kermanshah, Iran ! style=background:white colspan=7 | Paris, France ! style=background:white colspan=7 | Madrid, Spain ! style=background:white colspan=7 | Iowa City, Iowa ! style=background:white colspan=7 | Las Vegas, Nevada ! style=background:white colspan=7 | Baku, Azerbaijan ! style=background:white colspan=7 | Yerevan, Armenia ! style=background:white colspan=7 | Madrid, Spain ! style=background:white colspan=7 | Madison, Wisconsin ! style=background:white colspan=7 | New York City, New York ! style=background:white colspan=7 | Las Vegas, Nevada ! style=background:white colspan=7 | New York City, New York ! style=background:white colspan=7 | Istanbul, Turkey ! style=background:white colspan=7 | Madison, Wisconsin ! style=background:white colspan=7 | New York City, New York ! style=background:white colspan=7 | Las Vegas, Nevada ! style=background:white colspan=7 | Kazan, Russia ! style=background:white colspan=7 | Akron, Ohio ! style=background:white colspan=7 | Las Vegas, Nevada ! style=background:white colspan=7 | New York City, New York
NCAA Division I Championships Outstanding Wrestler
NCAA Division I
Big Ten Conference
;2011
NCAA Division I
Big Ten Conference
Endorsements
In 2015, Taylor and Adidas released a line of wrestling apparel labeled “M2” after Taylor's college nickname “Magic Man”. Taylor received the nickname "Magic Man" after a collegiate match in which he turned an unfavorable situation for himself into an advantage. The apparel line began with wrestling shoes and since has expanded to clothing, posters and Adidas sponsored events.