Communist purges in Serbia in 1944–45
The communist purges in Serbia in 1944–1945 are atrocities that were committed by members of the Yugoslav Partisan Movement and post-war communist authorities after they gained control over Serbia, against people perceived as war criminals, quislings and ideological opponents. Most of these purges were committed between October 1944 and May 1945. During this time, at least 55,973 people died of various causes, including death by execution or by illness in retention camps. The victims – vast majority of them deliberately murdered, without a trial – were of different ethnic backgrounds, but were mostly Germans, Serbs and Hungarians. The critics who oppose the naming of the purges a deliberate mass killing, among other things claim that the events were not officially planned out, but were simply unorganised vendetta of individuals due to post-war chaos. There is even a notion that the purges are a forgery, as many supposedly innocent victims from the proposed lists died in battles against partisans.
The exact number of victims remains controversial, as the ongoing investigation is not finished and probably never will. So far different sources provide different estimates regarding the number of victims. According to one source, at least 80,000 people were executed in the whole of Serbia, while another source states that the number of victims was more than 100,000. In Central Serbia there was some 30,000 victims, while the number of victims in northern Serbian province of Vojvodina includes about 56,000 Germans, between 20,000 and 40,000 Hungarians, and some 23,000–24,000 Serbs. The names of about 4,000 individual Germans who were killed by the Partisans are known, but it is estimated that many more ethnic Germans were executed. These events during the fall of 1944 are referred to as "bloody autumn" by some sources. In 2009, the government of Serbia formed a State Commission to investigate the secret burial places of victims after 12 September 1944. The Commission compiled a registry of names, basic biographical data, and details of persecution. The registry contains a total of 55,973 names, including 27,367 Germans, 14,567 Serbs and 6,112 Hungarians.
Background
During World War II, in 1941, Nazi Germany invaded and occupied Yugoslavia. Central Serbia was put under Military Administration in Serbia. Kosovo was attached to Italian protectorate of Albania, while eastern part of Serbia was occupied by Bulgaria. The Vojvodina region was divided into three occupation zones: Banat was placed under direct German control as an autonomous region within the area governed by the Military Administration in Serbia, Bačka was attached back to Horthy's Hungary and Syrmia was attached to the Independent State of Croatia.Axis had big problem to quell down partisan uprising led by Communist Party of Yugoslavia due to man shortage and rough terrain. Therefore, they heavily relied on auxiliary anticommunist forces drawn from various Yugoslav people. In Serbia they used Serbian Volunteer Corps, Serbian State Guard, and Chetniks of Kosta Pećanac and Dragoljub Mihailović. From ranks of German minority in Banat, Germany organized 7th SS Volunteer Mountain Division Prinz Eugen. Also some Hungarians in Bačka and Baranja joined Turan Hunters. From ranks of White Russian emigres, Germany recruited Russian Protective Corps.
Aside from military and paramilitary formations, many national organizations that weren't fascist or irendetist in its roots also showed support to occupying armies.
Since the beginning of the occupation, the occupying powers committed numerous war crimes against the civilian population of the region, especially against Serbs, Jews and Roma. Therefore, many citizens of Yugoslavia belonging to all ethnic groups joined the partisan resistance movement to fight against occupation. The victims of the Axis troops were mostly civilians, while some were the fighters of the partisan resistance movement. Vojvodina was a region with ethnically mixed population according to the various official censuses.
In their struggle against Axis forces, partisans viewed Chetniks as misled and continuously called them to surrender. Similar policy was conducted toward members of Croatian Home Guard. Those who did surrender were included in partisan ranks or were given amnesty. On August 17, 1944, Josip Broz Tito proclaimed the general amnesty for Chetniks and members of Croatian Home Guardson condition that they did not commit any crimes and join Partisans until September 15, 1944 as deadline. Members of voluntary anticommunist and quisling formations were excluded from the offer. This amnesty, as well as proclamation of king Peter II of September 12, 1944, that all armed formations should place under the command of Marshal Tito, led to a great drop in the ranks of the Chetnik and the Croatian Home Guard. According to Tito's order, former Chetniks and Home Guards, who, even after September 15, 1944, would cross over to the partisans would be deployed in the partisan units. Amnesty was again proclaimed on November 21, 1944, and again by the adoption of the Amnesty and Pardoning Act of 6 July 1945. Between 10 and 15 thousand Chetniks were amnestied in this way, which accounted for about a third to a half of Chetniks in Serbia at that time.
Central Serbia
The number of victims in Central Serbia is estimated at 30,000. According to Milovan Đilas, before communist forces entered Belgrade, their leaders decided that followers of Serbia's former pro-Axis puppet Government of National Salvation should be liquidated immediately. According to communist leaders, Belgrade was the main center of Serbian reaction and, due to that, it was designed to be "very carefully cleansed from anti-communist elements". The establishment of communist administration was, therefore, followed by a brutal showdown with notable persons that participated in the cultural, political and public life of the German-occupied territory of Serbia, and also with members of the rival Chetnik resistance movement who were defeated in a civil war.Vojvodina
In Vojvodina, most of the executions were performed during Military Administration in Banat, Bačka and Baranja, between October 1944 and January 1945.Background
At the end of 1944, Axis troops were defeated by the Red Army and the whole of Vojvodina came under the control of the Yugoslav partisan forces. On 17 October 1944, by the order of Josip Broz Tito, the Banat, Bačka and Baranja regions were placed under military administration. About the establishment of this military government, Josip Broz Tito said the following: "The liberation of Bačka, Banat and Baranja requires the quickest possible return to normal life and the establishment of the people's democratic power in these territories. The specific circumstances under which these territories had to live during the occupation, and a mission to fully avert all adversities inflicted to our people by the occupying forces and foreign ethnic elements colonized here, requires that, in the beginning, we concentrate all power in order to mobilize the economy and carry on the war of liberation more successfully".The partisan troops in Bačka had a very strict order, they had to "show the strongest possible determination against fifth columnists, especially against Germans and Hungarians".
The term "fifth column" is applied to the subversive and resistant forces and organizations left behind by a retreating enemy. The National Committee for People's Liberation and the Red Army had agreed on the necessary cooperation in due time.
Brigadier General Ivan Rukavina was appointed commander of the military administration. He was in constant and direct contact with Tito, the supreme commander. In his first decree, he ordered his troops to "protect the national future and the South Slavic character of the territories".
In the 28 October 1944 issue of Slobodna Vojvodina, the newspaper of the People's Liberation Front in Vojvodina, one member of the Regional Committee of the Communist Party of Yugoslavia summarized the intentions suggested from above, with the obvious aim to raise spirit for revenge by exaggerations and distortions:
Although we destroyed the occupying German and Hungarian hordes and drove them back to the west, we have not yet eradicated the roots of the poisonous weeds planted by them... The hundreds of thousands of foreigners who were settled on the territories where our ancestors had cleared the forests, drained the swamps, and created the conditions necessary for civilized life. These foreigners still kept shooting at our soldiers and the Soviet soldiers from the dark. They do everything they can to prevent the return to normal life, preparing, in the midst of this difficult situation, to stab us in the back again at the appropriate moment... The people feel that determined, energetic steps are needed to ensure the Yugoslav character of Bačka.
Ethnic composition of victims
Germans (Danube Swabians)
The estimated number range of Germans victims in Vojvodina is between 17,000 and 59,335. According to Friedrich Binder, the total number of the German victims in Yugoslavia was 56,736, of which 240 died while escaping in October 1944, 8,049 were executed by the Yugoslav partisans and 48,447 died in prison camps from starvation, illness and in the coldness.Serbian State commission formed in 2009 established the list of 27.367 German victims in total.
Before World War II, the German population of Vojvodina numbered about 350,000 people. Between 160.000 and 200.000 were left after the withdrawal of Nazi forces. As a consequence of the World War II events in Yugoslavia, the collaboration with Nazi forces and committed war crimes of the German community the Yugoslav Communist government took a reprisals on ethnic citizens of German origin in Yugoslavia: they had their citizenship revoked, their belongings were taken by force, and they were forced to share their houses with ethnic Serb, Montenegrin, Croat and Macedonian refugees from other parts of Yugoslavia who were colonized in Vojvodina.
Between 1944 and 1946, a prison camp system was established for all Vojvodina citizens of German origin in almost all settlements where they lived. In those camps, ethnic Germans were used as slave labor, they were tortured, beaten, and left to die from preventable illnesses and starvation. Some members of the German community were executed by Yugoslav Partisans in those camps. Yugoslav Partisans handed over some of the ethnic Germans to Soviet Red Army, who then took them to Siberia and used them for work in mines as slave labor. Some members of ethnic Germans of Vojvodina were expelled to Germany or Austria.
Serbs
After king Peter's speech via BBC on 12 September 1944, those Chetniks who didn't join Partisans became effectively outlaws. In time of the king's speech, Chetniks and Partisans were engaged in Battle of Jelova Gora, which ended with serious Chetnik defeat. Mihailović with his party fled to Bosnia, while smaller Chetnik groups remained in Serbia, hoping that Red Army would accept them as allies. When this did not materialize, those groups, joined by former Serbian State Guard, began retreat toward Bosnia through Sandžak, on flanks of retreating German Army Group E from Greece. On their route through Sandžak, Chetniks and Germans were harassed by Partisans and air raids from Allied Balkan Air Force.The number of the Serb victims in Vojvodina is estimated at about 23,000–24,000.
In 1944, in Rajina Šuma near Novi Sad, partisans executed about 200–250 Serbs, who were accused that they sympathized with the Chetnik movement of Draža Mihajlović. They were buried into two mass graves, which were discovered in 1991 during communal works in that area. After the entry of partisan forces into Novi Sad on 23 October 1944, by the order of general Josip Rukavina, mass arrests of respectable Serbs had begun. They mostly were reputable and rich householders, industrialists and intellectuals, who were seen as a possible threat for the new communist authorities. Order was carried out by the 11th Vojvodinian people's liberation brigade and most of the arrested citizens were executed until the middle of November.
Citizens who were executed included dr Miloš Petrović, dr Obrad Milutinović, Dragoljub Ristić, Pavle Tatić, Vojislav Matić, Miloš Kostić, Svetislav Vilovski and Đurica Vlaović, Milan – Peca Popović, Jovan Begović, Aleksandar Silber, Pera Savić, Fedor Radić, and Gaja Gračanin. Especially tragic fate is that of pre-war mayor dr Miloš Petrović, who was creditable for elevation of monument dedicated to Svetozar Miletić that still stands in the centre of Novi Sad, and who also helped in saving lives of hundreds of Serbs who were imprisoned in concentration camp "Šarvar" during Hungarian occupation.
State commission formed in 2009 after thorough investigation made a list of all victims, available on its official site. List includes a total of 14.567 Serb victims. 917 of them are from Vojvodina, and further 101 from Zemun.
Hungarians
Various sources provide very different numbers of Hungarians executed in Vojvodina at that time. "The Book of Evidence of Killed War Criminals in 1944/1945" published in Yugoslavia states that a total of 1,686 people were executed in Bačka of which approximately 1,000 people were presumed to be Hungarians. However, the estimation of historian Kasaš tells 5,000 executed Hungarians.According to other estimations, the number range of the executed Hungarians in Vojvodina may be between 40,000 and 50,000. Some sources claim that the most probable number of the executed Hungarians in Vojvodina was between 20,000 and 25,000, while others claim that it is about 35,000.
Some Hungarian houses were sacked and a number of Hungarian civilians were executed and tortured. Some women and children were raped. Some men who were able to work were deported to Siberia.
People of Hungarian nationality are third in terms of the number of dead after the liberation, according to the 2014 data from Serbian state commission. In 2014 there were 6,112 registered persons, of which 589 are alleged to have disappeared and 279 died in camps. Unlike in Banat, in Bačka there were drastic punishment of members of the Hungarian national minority, especially those found, often on the basis of witness statements, that took direct or indirect involvement in the January 1942 raid and in the suffering of the Serbian population in April 1941. Members of Arrow Cross Party were especially targeted, as well as members of collaborationist apparatus, leadership of the DMKSZ, but also and others that were considered to fall under the category of associates of the occupiers. The largest number of people of Hungarian ethnicity died after the liberation of Vojvodina was recorded in places where, during the occupation, the Hungarian army and local Hungarians participated in mass crimes against the Serbian, Jewish and Roma population. The largest number of Hungarians killed was recorded in the region of Šajkaška, which were affected by the January 1942 raid.
The attitude towards the Hungarians began to change from November 1944. The military administration of Banat, Bačka and Baranja warned that in some cases, especially in Bačka, mistakes were made and that the treatment of Germans was better than the Hungarians. In its instructions, it is pointed out that only those Hungarians who committed or incited crimes against the Slovene population were to be detained in the camps, and that Hungarians who did not fall into the category of war criminals should be released from camps. These guidelines are not accepted in all places with approval, especially in the Šajkaška region. In January and February 1945, some residents of Čurug and Mošorin demanded that all Germans and Hungarians should move out of these places, because their co-existence is impossible after events during the war. Almost the entire Hungarian population of Šajkaška was expelled and the largest number of detained in camps in Bački Jarak, Gajdobra and Mladenovo. Part was sent to Srem as a labor force in the preparation of the partisans for the breakthrough of the Syrmian Front and in repairing of the Belgrade-Zagreb railway. People detained in Bački Jarak were used as labor force for agricultural works. According to the book of the deceased from January to May 1945, due to poor conditions in the camp, 66 adults and 55 children from the age of one month to 18 years have died.
Nevertheless, the Hungarian population was accepted into partisans ranks. At the time of these events, the :sr:Петнаеста војвођанска ударна бригада|15th Vojvodina Shock Brigade "Sándor Petőfi" was formed from the Hungarians from area of Bačka Topola and Sombor. About ten thousand of Vojvodina Hungarians took part in the final operations for the liberation of Yugoslavia.
Rusyns
Some members of Rusyn population in Đurđevo were also targeted by partisan forces in 1944. According to Hungarian author Cseres, the majority of the Hungarian population of this village left with the retreating Hungarian army. The Yugoslav partisans then established control over this village and took their reprisals out on the Rusyns and Serbs who were sympathetic towards the Hungarians, the Serbian Royal Government or for their religious views. Several hundred Rusyns were executed and some prominent figures tortured.Serbian State commission formed in 2009 established the list of 40 Rusyn victims in total.
Aftermath
In June 2013, members of the Serbian Parliament adopted a declaration, which condemned the massacres and application of the principle of collective guilt against Hungarians in Vojvodina at the end of the Second World War. In response, Hungarian President János Áder apologised in Belgrade for the war crimes committed against civilian Serbs and Jewish people during the Hungarian occupation of Yugoslav territories.The history of investigations
I. The ''Federal Commission'' ("Državna komisija") – 1943
Even in the midst of the storm of the war, at the second session of the AVNOJ in Jajce, November 1943, a decision was made for a special task force to be formed to investigate the crimes committed by fascists at the territory of Yugoslavia during the war. It was named "Federal Commission for determination of the crimes conducted by the Occupators and their helpers during World War 2", and it immediately started its work. In following five years broad investigation was conducted nationwide. It is said that until 1948, this official body collected over a million cases of war crime, documented and reported.This investigation was very extensive, because the newly formed government wanted to collect the best possible set of data that can be presented in a demand for war reparations from Germany, Italy, Bulgaria and Hungary – countries responsible for the attack on Yugoslavia and violation of its sovereignty. Although this nationwide program concentrated only on the victims of fascism, it plays an important part in the completing of the historical picture. Even though the assessment of its results, and its methodology for collecting data would be different today, the work of this Commission is very important to the reconstruction of events, especially those that followed shortly after the war.
II. The ''Surveying Committee'' ("Anketni odbor") – 2001
The first extensive study, and also the first ever attempt to systematically analize the events that occurred between 1941 and 1948 on the territory of Serbia happened in 2001 on the initiative of the Assembly of the Autonomous province of Vojvodina.On January 22, 2001 in the building of the Assebly in Novi Sad, this governmental department formed a specialist group with a long name "Surveying Committee for investigation of the truth on the events that took place between 1941. until 1945. in Vojvodina" and this institution became a formal body of the Assembly of Autonomous province of Vojvodina.
This should be considered the first modern official investigation that took place after the Second World War, except for some studies done earlier in Slovenia.
III. The ''Vojvodina Academy'' ("VANU") – 2004
The work of the Assembly Committee was three years later taken over by Vojvodinian Academy of Sciences and Arts, where it was in a great deal extended. The Academy expanded the research for the period up to 1948, and to some extent even to 1952. Through their work an unbeliavable amount of 10 volumes with over 4000 pages of data was processed.The data was mainly collected from the Historic Archive of Vojvodina and the raw data was kept in the Museum of Vojvodina. The results were first published on paper in 2008. under the title "On the way to the truth. Book of victims of AP Vojvodina 1941-1948" Because of the enormous amount of text, forming 9 volumes there was not enough money to publish it, so just 10 copies were printed. This makes this work inaccessible even to the researchers.
Although the results were raw and yet unstudied to detail, they were already shocking to the public.
Important step forward was the collecting of data about all known retention camps, and the victims of the period are classified by ethnic structure and also age and sex, as well as by the place of death. The weak point of this stage of the investigation was, because of the lack of material means, that about 20% of available data still remained unprocessed. As on the positive side, leader of the project dr. Dragoljub Živković claimed that much effort has been put and a lot of attention given to the task that there would be no duplicate entries.
The public was presented only with preliminary results, primarily through the media. The representatives said that in Bačka, Banat, Srem and Baranja, and also in other countries but from the territory of Vojvodina, between 1941. and 1948. a total of 86.881 civilians perished. The full set of data with exact numbers is available in the published volume of the "Na putu ka istini. Imenik stradalih stanovnika AP Vojvodine 1941-1948".
It is important to say that this is not data that summarises victims of the 1944/45 communist purges, because it does not separates specifically the circumstances of death, but it is a raw list, with documents and literature, that was intended for future examination by experts. There is also an important statement that should be considered by the scholars of victimology, that this study showed independently that more than 12.000 inhabitants of Vojvodina, of different nationality ended up and were killed in Jasenovac and also in Banjica.
It is important to stress that the publication pertains only to the civilians that lost their lives in the period 1941–1948, in retention camps, through executions etc. and not to military personnel who died in battles during the war. Two very large, unfortunate numbers demonstrate this: among the persons who lost their lives the percentage of women was 49,90% in Jews and about 60% in the group of the ethnic Germans.
IV. The ''State Commission'' ("Državna komisija") – 2009
On July 9, 2009 the government of Serbia founded a "Commission for the secret graves of victims killed after September 12, 1944". The choice of the date is connected with the last stage of liberation from the occupator, when on October 20, 1944, with the help from the advancing Red Army, Belgrade was liberated. Soon after that the war activity ceased, but it marked a new period of sufferings. Even before the official declaration of the end of the war, atrocities against civilians that were assumed unsympathizing with communist rule started to happen. For example, in Vojvodina the first Hungarian victims were shot, some of them openly, convicted of being a fascist, in the middle of September 1944 in Bečej, where also the local German population was forced to wear white armbands as a sign that they will be sent to forced labor.The mission of the 2009 Commission was to locate and mark all secret graves in which bodies of those shot after the 1944. liberation lay, and also to exhume them, for the purpose of determining the cause and investigation of the circumstances of death. The first exhumations took place in 2010, in the vicity of Zaječar.
April 29 of the same year marked a new era in the investigation of the 1944/45 events, as the government ruled a decision to remove the stamp of secrecy from the classified documents of the Archives, where the lists of liquidated persons and other important documents resided. Now the researchers were for the first time able to look at those papers. This was an important step forward, because this was the first time that a governmental investigation focused mainly at the victims of the "red terror".
V. The ''Academic Commission'' ("Međuakademska komisija") – 2010
After the collecting of data from literature and archives to build a database, the phase of in-depth scientific study and analysis followed, which is still going on. For this purpose the governments of Hungary and Serbia agreed to establish a joint Commission. This separate task force, that officially formed 15, December 2010 in Belgrade, is called "Hungarian–Serbian academic Joint Committee for the civilian victims during and after the Second World War in Vojvodina, 1941-1948".The Hungarian section of the Joint Committee held its inaugural meeting shortly after, at January 6th. 2011. in Budapest.
The process of rehabilitation
The problem has two dimensions, one at personal level of victims and their living relatives, and one at a larger scale, on the level of the society where the crimes were committed. Modern countries put efforts into dealing with all World War II irregularities, to clarify their history which sadly includes many gruesome happenings, both by the war both in the post war period.At the same time many have risen the question, could even this generation take over the responsibility for the misdoings of past political regimes that were in power seven deccades ago? Should, for example modern day Serbia and its citizens collectively be questioned about the crimes committed in the old Yugoslavia? Certainly not, but regardless, any civilised society will do all in its power to sort out the black spots of the past. Its moral duty is to do all that is possible to present past as it happened, and not a distorted version of it.
On the personal level, each victims' family looks for ways to find out when, how and why their relative was executed, or if went missing to get the information about his/her whereabout. It is important to know, in cases where it was not clear, if the person was charged with a crime that deserves death and if he/she was legally and justfully prosecuted before the punishment took place. In cases where the grave still needs to be found, investigation is proposed to locate it, and in cases where the victims be proven innocent, exhumation and regular funeral is expected. The mass graves also need memorial signs over them, and that is a direct duty of the government in territory of which the crimes were conducted.
The question of purges is especially important in relation to bordering countries. In case of Serbia and Hungary it is vital to assuring the future good-neighbor relations between the two countries. So excessive bilateral negotiations started between the governments, and a decision was made to start joint investigation, with involvement of professionals and academic institutions from both countries.
Case studies
It is expected that the first to be rehabilited will be public figures, such as teachers, priests and Church dignitaries, those that were executed or persecuted with clear aim to intimidate the wider public through fear, and set a harsh example. During the purges in Vojvodina, between 13 and 22 Catholic clerics were reported to be missing, 13 of whom was proven to be dead.For example, if it was known or suspected that the priest was innocent, official forensic and court procedure was on the way. In some cases a memorial or a bust was already erected, even before the trial was completed.