Christopher Columbus, an explorer from Genoa, Italy, arrives in Spain with his son seeking funds for a trip to India. He obtains an introduction at court from Father Perez, the former confessor for Queens Isabella. Columbus is opposed b Francisco de Bobadilla, who uses Beatriz to distract Columbus, However eventually the Queen agrees to finance Columbus's ships, the Nina, the Pinta and the Santa Maria, on its journey. On the trip over, the crew threaten mutiny. Columbus promises to turn back if no land is found in three days. On the third night, Columbus sees a light and they reach the New World. Columbus returns to Spain a hero but continues to face opposition at court, even has his discoveries help turn Spain into a rich country.
The film was a passion project for producer Sydney Box who in 1945 had a huge success with The Seventh Veil. In September 1946 Box announced he would make the film from Sabatini's novel for the United KingdomMoving Picture Company. Finance would come from the Rank Organisation. The film was part of a deliberate attempt by Rank to break into the American market, following the path blazed with films like Henry V and Caesar and Cleopatra. John Woolf, head of international distribution for Rank, said in October 1946 that:
Before we smacked Henry V and Caesar and Cleopatra into the American Markets, we were getting a poor showing in the United States. Although the most optimistic figures have been put out in London about the achievements of Henry and Caesar, in fact they have had to fight hard to make their way. The important thing to remember is this— that these big films enabled us to break through the highly controlled theatre circuits in America. We are using them as a spearhead to get a showing of British films.
For a time it seemed there would be a rival movie on the same subject produced by Edward Small from a biography by David Lawrence. This film was not made. When Box became head of Gainsborough Pictures he immediately put the project in development at that studio. In January 1947 Sabatini was reportedly working on the script.
Casting
In October 1946 Box said he wanted a young, virile actor to play the lead. Stewart Granger was originally mentioned. In January 1947 Arturo de Córdova was announced as star. In August 1947 Sydney Box arrived in Hollywood to sign a star. He met with James Mason. Then in September he announced he had signed Fredric March and Florence Eldridge to play the leads. "It's a great part", said March.
Shooting
March arrived in England in April 1948 for what was meant to be a five-month shoot. Studio filming took place at Pinewood and there was location filming in Barbados. March had recently had an operation and suffered a relapse while in London. Two ships, replicas of the Nina and Santa Maria were built especially for the film and in April 1948 they were shipped from Spain to London. Shooting was often difficult. The replica of the Santa Maria broke its moorings during a squall in the West Indies and drifted for two nights and a day with people on board before it was rescued. Then a fire broke out and the ship was burnt. It had to be rebuilt at a cost of £100,000 because scenes set on it had yet to be shot. March collapsed one day due to heatstroke.
Reshoots
A new subplot was added towards the end of shooting involving the romance between Columbus and the sister of his lieutenant. March was reportedly very disappointed with the final film. The Francoist Spanish government considered the portrait of Columbus to be unflattering. In response the leading Spanish studio CIFESA produced Dawn of America, which portrayed Columbus as a more daring figure.
Reception
Critical
The New York Times called it "largely an uninspired succession of legendary but lifeless episodes."
Box Office
In April 1949 J. Arthur Rank told Hedda Hopper he thought the film would be his most successful of 1949. However the film failed to recoup its enormous cost at the box office.
