Hill signed for Leigh from local Wigan amateur club New Springs Lions in 2004, and started his career as a or before moving to, progressing through Leigh's service area, scholarship and youth ranks before making his first senior appearance for Leigh in the 2005 Super League X season, during a 8–74 defeat by St. Helens. In 2006, Hill won the Northern Rail Cup with Leigh after consolidating his place in the side. He toured Australia with Great Britain Under-18s in this same year. 2011 saw Hill win his second Northern Rail Cup trophy with Leigh, featuring as Halifax were defeated 16-20 at Blackpool's Bloomfield Road Stadium. Hill accumulated a couple of accolades with Leigh; firstly in reaching 100 appearances for the club, and also being the most recent -forward for Leigh to score a hat-trick of tries. After missing only one game in two years, he was made captain of Leigh in 2010.
In 2011, Hill's impressive displays in the Championship saw him earn a three-year deal with Warrington in Super League, which saw him join the Warrington squad in 2012, remaining with Leigh on a dual registration until the end of the 2011 season. In light of this, his then-coach Ian Millward predicted future national caps for Hill, with his nurturing at Warrington. Hill was selected to start in the 2012 Challenge Cup Final victory over the Leeds Rhinos at Wembley Stadium. At the end of Hill's first season with Warrington, Chris was named as player of the season, players’ player of the season and won the Vice President's award, thus taking each of the major accolades at the Warrington end of season awards night. He played in the 2012 Super League Grand Final defeat by the Leeds Rhinos at Old Trafford. He played in the 2013 Super League Grand Final defeat ny the Wigan Warriors at Old Trafford. In 2016, Hill was named club captain of the Wolves. This was a successful year overall for the Wolves under Hill, as they reached both finals and won their first piece of silverware since 2016, when they won the League Leaders' Shield, the second time in the club's history. Hill was named in the Dream team for the season, and was also the Top Metre Maker of the season. He was rewarded for this amazing season with a contract extension with the club, which will keep him with the wolves until at least November 2021 He played in the 2016 Challenge Cup Final defeat ny Hull F.C. at Wembley Stadium. He played in the 2016 Super League Grand Final defeat by the Wigan Warriors at Old Trafford. He played in the 2018 Challenge Cup Final defeat by the Catalans Dragons at Wembley Stadium. He played in the 2018 Super League Grand Final defeat by the Wigan Warriors at Old Trafford. He played in the 2019 Challenge Cup Final victory over St. Helens at Wembley Stadium.
