A late-comer to VFL football, Goddard played a game for South Fremantle in 1900 and spent five years at North Fremantle before going to Victoria; and, in June 1903, he was suspended for entering the opposition's change rooms after the match and assaulting one of its players. He had previously visited the eastern state in 1904 when he toured with the Western Australian interstate football team.
VFL (South Melbourne)
Goddard, who was a centreman, performed well in his first season at South Melbourne but missed out on a place in their 1907 Grand Final team. He played fourteen games for South Melbourne in 1908.
Application for clearance (1909)
In 1909, having played in all of South Melbourne's pre-season practice games, yet not having been being selected to play, and " seen a couple of the Carlton players who told him that he could get a game" and " one of the committee, and decided to apply for a clearance", Goddard took the extraordinary step of independently applying for an clearance to Carlton. The VFL Permit Committee met on 19 May 1909, and considered Goddard's request. An in camera discussion was held between the Committee, Goddard, Jack Worrall, the Carlton delegate, and Henry Hawkins Skinner, the South Melbourne delegate. Noting that, although South Melbourne had agreed to release Goddard – having informed Goddard "that he will not be selected in our team as we do not considered him good enough as a player" – it also noted that Jack Worrall stated that "This application has been made without the consent of my committee, and I further wish to state the committee do not desire the services of Mr. Goddard". The Committee refused his application; and, "in answer to a question by Goddard as to whether he could apply to go to another club, said, "Your clearance is not sufficient to entitle you to a permit to play with any club"." As a consequence, Goddard did not play anywhere at all in the VFL in 1909; and, although there was talk of him possibly going to play with Prahran in the VFA, there is no evidence of him ever having done so.
VFL (Carlton)
He was granted a clearance from South Melbourne to Carlton in 1910; and played there as a defender. In a tumultuous season for Carlton, which began with the sacking of coach Jack Worrall and ended with two players suspended for taking bribes, Carlton still managed to make the Grand Final. Goddard played at back pocket in the 1910 Grand Final, in which Carlton lost to Collingwood by 14 points.
VFL (St Kilda)
In 1911, he crossed to St Kilda, with whom he played seven senior games.
WAFL
Goddard continued to play in the WAFL well into his 30s and was a member of East Fremantle's 1914 premiership side. His final season was in 1918 ; and only an injury stopped him from ending his career with another premiership, with East Fremantle winning that year's Grand Final.
