ABC Mystery Theater, also known as just simply Mystery Theater or Mystery Theatre, was an American radio anthology, crime and mystery series from the 1950s. The program starred originally, actor Robert Carroll in the title role of Inspector Mark Saber, a British detective from The Homicide Squad then by actor Les Damon for seasons two and three. The program also centered on Saber's assistant Sgt. Tim Maloney, originally portrayed by character actor James Westerfield for the first half of season one, actor Douglas Chandler for the second half of season one and finally by character actor Walter Burke for seasons two and three. The program was broadcast over the ABC for 115 episodes and three seasons from October 3, 1951-June 30, 1954. While ABC Radio broadcast ABC Mystery Theater, ABC Television broadcast a program with the same format, storyline, plot and characters entitled Saber of London in which actors Tom Conway and Donald Gray portrayed Mark Saber. Saber of London was broadcast over the American and National Broadcasting Companies from 1951-1960.
Overview
ABC Mystery Theater was broadcast from 1951-1954, with two original seasons of scripts and one season of repeats from the second season. Season one introduced Inspector Mark Saber of The Homicide Squad and his able assistant, Sergeant Tim Maloney. For season one, character actor Robert Carroll was heard as Inspector Mark Saber. Sergeant Tim Maloney was portrayed by James Westerfield then Douglas Chandler. For seasons two and three, Les Damon, of radio's The Adventures of the Falcon and The Adventures of the Thin Man played the part of Inspector Saber and Walter Burke played the part of Sgt. Maloney.
Synopsis
ABC Mystery Theater premiered on October 3, 1951, to fairly neutral reviews. The program introduced listeners to the work life of Mark Saber. Saber is the senior inspector in a large metropolitan city's Homicide Squad. The division Saber is in is one that deals exclusively with murders of any kind but only murders. Most viewers and critics felt as though the concept of a different murder every week would eventually get old. But despite the negative reviews, ABC radio ordered a second season of episodes to premiere in the fall of 1952. During its first season, ABC Mystery Theater ran directly against the similarly themed CBS Mystery Theatre. During its second season, the program was put up against CBS's Hearthstone of The Death Squad. Hearthstone of the Death Squad reproduced broadcasts from the two years of CBS Mystery Theatre repackaged as their own series. The immediate similarities were obvious among listeners such as CBS's "Death Squad" vs ABC's Homicide Squad, CBS's "Inspector" vs ABC's Inspector and the metropolitan murders which were the plots for each episode of both programs. They often ran on the same day and in some instances in the same time slot. In the end, listeners were getting weary of both CBS's Hearthstone and ABC's Mystery Theater and their similarities and neither of the two stories survived the 1952-1953 radio season. The series ran for another season in which the episodes were just slightly modified versions of second season broadcasts and the program finally concluded on June 30, 1954, after its 115th broadcast.
Television
Two days after ABC Mystery Theater premiered on the radio, Saber of London premiered on the ABC Television Network. In the televised series, Mark Saber, a British homicide detective who works in the homicide department of a large American city and his trusty assistant, Sergeant Tim Maloney (portrayed by James Burke. The series aired at various times on ABC between 1951 and 1957, with a year and a half absence from the screen between June 1954 and December 1955. Saber of London was renamed and switched to NBC beginning in September 1957, when it aired at 7:30 p.m. EST on Fridays, opposite Leave It to Beaver, then on CBS, and The Adventures of Rin Tin Tin on ABC. In the 1958-1959 season, Saber of London switched to 7 p.m. Sundays, opposite CBS's Lassie. In its last year, 1959–1960, it was moved a half-hour earlier just outside prime time to 6:30 EST on Sundays.
Cast and characters
Inspector Mark Saber
Inspector Mark Saber is the main protagonist of the radio program. Saber works for the homicide department of an undisclosed metropolitan city in the United States. Originally, Saber was portrayed by veteran actor Robert Carroll. Carroll was replaced after the end of the program's first season and was replaced by veteran radio performer Les Damon. Damon would portray this title role for the remainder of the radio program.
Sgt. Tim Maloney
Sergeant Tim Maloney of the Metropolitan Homicide Department is the trusty and able assistant to Inspector Saber. He was originally portrayed by James Westerfield portrayed Maloney but was replaced by Douglas Chandler, an actor, halfway through season one. Chandler was eventually replaces by an actor named Walter Burke who remained through the course of the show.
