1931 Auckland Rugby League season
The 1931 Auckland Rugby League season was its 23rd.
First Year of the Fox Memorial Shield
It was the first season where the premier senior teams had competed for the Fox Memorial Shield. Prior to 1931 the trophy awarded was the Monteith Shield, and before that the Myers Cup. The donor of the Monteith Shield wrote to the league asking permission to withdraw the trophy from club competition and that the league play for a new trophy named after Edward Vincent Fox who had passed away the season previous and who had been heavily involved in Auckland Rugby League for a long period of time. The new trophy was being donated by friends of Fox. The trophy was finished and presented to the league in September. It was described thus; "measuring 27 inches across by 22 inches deep, the base is a handsome sample of polished rimu, with overlay of contrasting puriri, on which is an ornate centrepiece in oxidised silver depicting an incident of play in the New Zealand v Australia match of 1926". The donators of the trophy even went to the extent of sending the silver piece to England to have it effectively reproduced.The Fox Memorial Shield was won by Marist Old Boys who defeated Devonport United 12–5 in the final round to win the competition by 3 competition points over the same side. Devonport United did however win the Roope Rooster competition defeating Ponsonby United in the final, and they beat Marist Old Boys to win the Stormont Trophy. Alongside these feats Devonport also won the inaugural reserve grade competition with a 5–5 draw in the final securing them the 1 competition point they needed. Richmond Rovers won the Stallard Cup by winning the reserve grade knockout competition. On the final day of the season Mr. Samuel Harris of the Newton Rangers team had a heart attack while running with the ball in the final of the Seven-A-Side charity tournament. The game was called off with no result given. He had played with Newton for 2 seasons after moving to Auckland from Hikurangi. He was single and 26 years of age.
The Auckland City Council Parks Committee designated the following of its grounds to the league code: Auckland Domain, Outer Domain, Victoria Park, Auckland, Walker Road, Western Springs, Grey Lynn Park, and 1 additional ground at Grey Lynn to alternate between rugby and league.
Financial statement and annual report
The annual report to be filed at the annual general meeting showed that the league had a £9,711 5/9 surplus with total assets of £10,534 19/4. As there were smaller crowds in 1930 the gate receipts were £2,282 12/, down from £3,465 10/5 in 1929. The Junior Management Committee reported that the number of juniors registered was 1,930 compared with 984 the previous year, and 63 teams took the field. At the annual general meeting Mr. James Carlaw said that "this is a very important meeting, as we have now reached our twenty-first birthday, and have developed from childhood to manhood". Mr. Phelan presented trophies to the various winners from the previous season. At the Devonport annual meeting Mr. A. Ferguson who was a member of the New Zealand Council and who was presiding over the meeting said that the league game in New Zealand needed to follow the Australian model. He stated that they "demonstrated the value of physical fitness, which was produced by intensive, scientific training".Senior competition restructuring and Carlaw Park gate takings
An early key development was that a management committee meeting which also included the special committee setup the previous year to look into the restructuring of the Senior A and Senior B competitions adjusted their plans. It had been decided at the end of the 1930 season to reduce the Senior A competition from eight teams to six, thus forcing teams into mergers. This was adjusted to seven teams after this meeting. The teams would be Devonport, Richmond Rovers, Ellerslie-Otahuhu, Marist Old Boys,,City Newton, and Ponsonby United. The Kingsland team which had been removed from the A grade asked for permission to join with the Marist Old Boys.The B grade was still to be eliminated. The league would encourage B grade players to try out for the reserve grade teams in the A grade clubs.
In a major development for the rugby league game in Auckland the special committee recommended that winning teams would be granted 12.5% of the net gate takings each weekend with losing teams sharing a "trifle less". The league would also enforce a rule where every Senior A club must field a reserve grade team "of sufficient calibre to satisfy the management committee". If they failed to do so they would be vulnerable to being removed from the A grade. The league also reserved the right to set the two lowest teams together at the end of the season against each other in a match and eliminating the losers, or compelling them to improve their standard of play or withdraw from the league.
Eastern Suburbs Tour of New Zealand
In mid October the Eastern Suburbs club team from Sydney toured New Zealand. They played three matches at Carlaw Park against Devonport, a combined Marist-Devonport team, and an Auckland colts side.Rule changes
At the Management Committee meeting prior to the start of the season it was decided to adhere to the latest rules, where a team forcing the ball in their own in goal area would take a drop kick from the 25-yard line as opposed from their own try line. There was an adjustment to the weight allowance from the fourth grade down, and sixth grade players should be under 18 and a half on 1 May. At a following Management Committee meeting it was reported that the English Rugby League had advised that at scrum put in's the loose head would be transferred from the defending team to the attacking team.On 15 August a referee was assaulted by a player after a match between the City and Newmarket Fourth Grade teams at Western Springs. He had ordered off a player from each team. The City player came back on the field and his team refused to remove him so the referee called the match off. He was then harassed by a number of players and one of them then fought with him, "the pair rolled on the ground fighting for a few minutes, the referee holding his own until some spectators intervened and separated" them.
New clubs at Papakura and Glenora, and several amalgamations
On March 26 the Papakura Rugby League club was formed with 60 players enrolling. They applied to the Papakura Town Board for use of the reserve at Papakura. This was granted as the entire club had switched over from the Rugby Union game thereby meaning they had no competition for the field. The council said that if a representative rugby game was being played on the field then the league team could use Prince Edward Park. On Saturday, 18 April they played a practice match with Mount Wellington at Papakura at 3pm. The match was won by Mount Wellington by 8 points to 5. Papakura's points came from an unconverted try to Johnstone, and I. Wilson kicked a penalty goal. They held their first social on the evening of Wednesday 22 April at the Paragon Theatre.The Kingsland club amalgamated with the Marist club which meant that their senior players would be joining those of Marist. Kingsland were already an amalgamated club involving Kingsland and Grafton Athletic. This placed Marist as one of the early favourites to win the Senior Grade. This was discussed in an article on the prospects of all the teams in the New Zealand Herald.
The Ellerslie, Otahuhu, and Mangere clubs combined to form a senior team with the Mangere Senior B team being regraded to first junior with the team playing as part of the Ellerslie-Otahuhu side. However Mangere Rugby League Football Club then sent a deputation to a Management Committee meeting asking to be able to play as a separate institution as a junior club rather than be a part of the Ellerslie-Otahuhu amalgamation. They wished to be affiliated to the league under their own name rather than amalgamate with Ellerslie. Several speakers were heard by the league and they said that they wished to play league football but maintain their own identity as a Māori team. The League said that there should be a conference with Ellerslie and in the meantime they would play for one week with Ellerslie. At a league meeting on 27 May the league decided to uphold their earlier ruling and enforce the amalgamation with the decision reviewed at the end of the season. It was expressed that the Mangere players were willing to play as the league suggested. Mr. Jim Rukutai suggested that Mangere be granted permission to retain their identity for twelve months, subject to all transfers being through the Ellerslie-Otahuhu United Club. The chairman of the league said "he did not think that there was any objection to Mangere playing as the Mangere section of the amalgamated club, but it was the duty of the League to uphold Ellerslie-Otahuhu Club". In the meantime he thought "moral suasion should be used by the members and the position would right itself". At the Management Committee meeting on 10 June it was reported by the chairman that the Mangere and Ellerslie clubs had reached a satisfactory agreement and that "the Māori senior team,… was willing to continue playing the league code. It was intended that Mangere should apply for the resignation of its players who had already played for Ellerslie" The matter would be deferred for one week.
It was announced at a City Rovers club meeting that the Parnell club had amalgamated with them. They would enter teams in the senior, reserve senior, first junior, third intermediate, fourth, fifth, sixth, and seventh grades, and also in the primary school competition. Ten of the Parnell senior B players were regraded to first class juniors and would play for that particular City Rovers side.
In June a new club was registered in the Glen Eden district and was named Glenora. They entered a team in the third grade intermediate.
Fox Memorial Shield (Senior Grade Championship)
The Senior Grade was reduced from 8 teams to 7 for the 1931 season. Each team had to field a reserve side and their matches were to be played prior to the A team's matches at the same venue.Senior A grade standings
Senior A Grade Fixtures
In Round 1 Marist won after time however the play was continued erroneously. Time was up but the time keeper allowed additional tackles and did not ring the bell until after the winning try had been scored. Richmond protested the result and after multiple meetings it was eventually decided by the league Management Committee to replay the match.The Round 3 match between Richmond and Newton was the first ever senior league match played at Western Springs Stadium which had opened for cycling and field sports in 1929.
The Round 12 match at Devonport between the hosts and Ellerslie-Otahuhu was one with paid entry after permission was granted by the Devonport Borough Council. A sum of £12 5/ was raised to assist the Devonport Welfare League's funds.
The Round 13 matches were played in terrible conditions which saw the cancellation of almost all league in Auckland. The Ellerslie-Otahuhu v Marist match played at Papatoetoe was abandoned at halftime with the result 21–3 in favour of Marist standing as the final score.
Date | Score | Score | Venue | |||
Round 1 | 2 May | Devonport | 23 | City | 18 | Carlaw Park # 1, 3pm |
– | 2 May | Marist | 11 | Richmond | 10 | Carlaw Park # 2, 3pm |
– | 2 May | Ellerslie-Otahuhu | 5 | Newton | 5 | Ellerslie, 3pm |
Round 2 | 9 May | Marist | 20 | Ponsonby | 9 | Carlaw Park # 1, 3pm |
– | 9 May | Richmond | 28 | City | 15 | Carlaw Park # 2, 3pm |
– | 9 May | Devonport | 28 | Newton | 0 | Carlaw Park # 1, 1:45pm |
Round 3 | 16 May | Ponsonby | 24 | City | 13 | Carlaw Park # 1, 3pm |
– | 16 May | Devonport | 23 | Ellerslie-Otahuhu | 12 | Carlaw Park # 2, 3pm |
– | 16 May | Richmond | 6 | Newton | 3 | Western Springs Stadium, 3pm |
Round 4 | 23 May | City | 16 | Marist | 2 | Carlaw Park # 1, 3pm |
– | 23 May | Richmond | 17 | Ellerslie-Otahuhu | 9 | Carlaw Park # 2, 3pm |
– | 23 May | Ponsonby | 20 | Newton | 8 | Western Springs Stadium, 3pm |
Round 5 | 30 May | Devonport | 13 | Richmond | 5 | Carlaw Park # 1, 3pm |
– | 30 May | Marist | 18 | Newton | 9 | Carlaw Park # 2, 3pm |
– | 30 May | Ellerslie-Otahuhu | 8 | Ponsonby | 24 | Ellerslie, 3pm |
Round 1 Replay | 6 June | Marist | 13 | Richmond | 7 | Carlaw Park # 1, 3pm |
Round 6 | 13 June | Devonport | 9 | Ponsonby | 8 | Carlaw Park # 1, 3pm |
– | 13 June | City | 0 | Newton | 0 | Western Springs, 3pm |
– | 13 June | Marist | 39 | Ellerslie-Otahuhu | 3 | Carlaw Park # 2, 3pm |
Round 7 | 20 June | Marist | 11 | Devonport | 4 | Carlaw Park # 1, 3pm |
– | 20 June | Richmond | 2 | Ponsonby | 2 | Carlaw Park # 2, 3pm |
– | 20 June | City | 20 | Ellerslie-Otahuhu | 2 | Auckland Domain # 1, 3pm |
Round 8 | 27 June | Devonport | 16 | City | 5 | Carlaw Park # 1, 3pm |
– | 27 June | Newton | 14 | Ellerslie-Otahuhu | 3 | Carlaw Park # 2, 3pm |
– | 27 June | Marist | 8 | Richmond | 3 | Western Springs Stadium, 3pm |
Round 9 | 4 July | Marist | 25 | Ponsonby | 10 | Carlaw Park # 1, 3pm |
– | 4 July | Richmond | 11 | City | 8 | Carlaw Park # 2, 3pm |
– | 4 July | Devonport | 20 | Newton | 5 | Devonport, 3pm |
Round 10 | 11 July | Devonport | 14 | Richmond | 10 | Carlaw Park # 1, 3pm |
– | 11 July | Ponsonby | 20 | Ellerslie-Otahuhu | 17 | Carlaw Park # 2, 3pm |
– | 11 July | Marist | 17 | Newton | 9 | Western Springs, 3pm |
Round 11 | 18 July | Marist | 18 | City | 10 | Carlaw Park # 1, 3pm |
– | 18 July | Richmond | 32 | Ellerslie-Otahuhu | 3 | Carlaw Park # 2, 3pm |
– | 18 July | Ponsonby | 12 | Newton | 7 | Northcote, 3pm |
Round 12 | 25 July | Ponsonby | 18 | City | 7 | Carlaw Park # 1, 3pm |
– | 25 July | Richmond | 8 | Newton | 0 | Carlaw Park #2, 3pm |
– | 25 July | Devonport | 12 | Ellerslie-Otahuhu | 6 | Devonport Domain, 3pm |
Round 13 | 1 Aug | Devonport | 13 | Ponsonby | 0 | Carlaw Park # 1, 3pm |
– | 1 Aug | Newton | 23 | City | 10 | Carlaw Park # 2, 3pm |
– | 1 Aug | Marist | 21 | Ellerslie-Otahuhu | 3 | Papatoetoe, 3pm |
Round 14 | 8 Aug | Marist | 12 | Devonport | 5 | Carlaw Park # 1, 3pm |
– | 8 Aug | Richmond | 14 | Ponsonby | 5 | Carlaw Park # 2, 3pm |
– | 8 Aug | Ellerslie-Otahuhu | 14 | City | 10 | Ellerslie Racecourse, 3pm |
Roope Rooster knockout competition
The semi-final between Ponsonby required extra time as it was tied 20–20 at the end of normal time. This was very rare as usually tied games were replayed. Ponsonby went on to win 28–20.Date | Score | Score | Venue | |||
Round 1 | 5 Sep | Ponsonby | 24 | City | 12 | Carlaw Park # 1, 3:15pm |
– | 5 Sep | Devonport | 41 | Newton | 8 | Carlaw Park # 2, 3pm |
– | 5 Sep | Richmond | 15 | Ellerslie-Otahuhu | 11 | Carlaw Park # 1, 1:45pm |
semi-final | 12 Sep | Ponsonby | 28 | Richmond | 20 | Carlaw Park # 2, 3:15pm |
semi-final | 12 Sep | Devonport | 11 | Marist | 8 | Carlaw Park # 1, 3:15pm |
Final | 19 Sep | Devonport | 34 | Ponsonby | 17 | Carlaw Park # 1, 3:15pm |
Stormont Shield
Senior Reserve Grade standings
The standings include the 'final' between Devonport and Ponsonby which was a 5–5 draw. This meant Devonport won the title as they finished the competition with one more point that Ponsonby. A Round 11 result between Marist and City is unknown as it was not reported in the newspapers while the score between Devonport and Ellerslie-Otahuhu in Round 12 is also unknown, though Devonport were the victor.Senior Reserve grade fixturesThe Round 13 matches at Carlaw Park were cancelled due to the poor weather conditions and the necessity to protect the ground for the Senior matches to follow immediately afterwards.
Reserve grade knockout competition (Stallard Cup)Charity day tournament and death of a playerOn 31 October a Charity Day was held at Carlaw Park. It featured a Seven-A-Side tournament, an 'old timers' match, a match between the referees and St Johns Ambulance, and several running races. The proceeds would all go to the St John Ambulance Brigade. Mr. Samuel Harris of the Newton team collapsed and died from heart failure a few minutes from time in the final. He had played in their earlier matches and had participated in a running race but had complained of feeling too unwell to run again. He collapsed while running with the ball and despite immediate attention from members of St, John Ambulance he died almost immediately. The match was called off. Harris had joined Newton in 1930 and was originally from Hikurangi. His funeral was held in Hikurangi on 4 November.
Lower grades and other club matchesLower grade teamsThe Mid-Week competition which was running once again was made up of nine teams. It was decided to allocate the Monteith Shield to the championship. This had formerly been awarded to the winner of the Senior grade champions, but as of this year the newly presented Fox Memorial Shield would replace it. The Waitemata Shield would be awarded to the team scoring the most championship points in the second round, and the "Nuko" Cup to the winner of the two lower teams on the ladder. Marist were awarded the Davis Shield for scoring the most competition points in the junior grades.Grades were made of the following teams with the winning team in bold:
Representative seasonIt was a very quiet year on the representative team front. There was a match played between North Island and South Island, but the Auckland team's only match was for the Northern Union Cup against Northland. In a surprise result Northland had defeated South Auckland to lift the trophy. Auckland challenged for it but could only manage a 19 all draw and so Northland retained it. Auckland junior teams played two matches and a colts side played against the touring Eastern Suburbs team from Sydney who were the premiers of the New South Wales Rugby League.Representative fixturesOnly a small number of fixtures were played in the 1931 season partly owing to the fact that Auckland did not hold the Northern Union Cup. Also the touring Eastern Suburbs team from Sydney had matches with club sides organised for them.
Annual general meetings and club news
|